LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

Help Choosing Compact Miter Saw

Tags
miter saw
2 reading
2.6K views 12 replies 10 participants last post by  northwoodsman  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
Hi All. Just moved into a house recently and have plenty of new projects to keep me busy for a while…planter boxes, pentagonal tree bench, new workbench for the garage with drawers and cabinets, etc.

I've got a tiny garage shop space, so I'm trying to look for smaller portable tools where possible. My thinking is that if I get a contractor table saw (perhaps the Bosch 4100XC-10) and supplement that with a small 8-1/2" sliding miter saw, that should cover everything I'll realistically need to do. Does that seem reasonable? I know I can't cut a 4×4 on the miter saw, but if I'm using a 4x I most likely need just a rough cut and I'll make due with a circular saw or a couple passes with the miter saw.

That said, I'm considering the Bosch CM8S or the Makita LS0815F. Would love to hear recommendations on which one to go with. Any other thoughts would be appreciated, as well.

Thanks in advance!
 
#3 · (Edited by Moderator)
This one may be worth considering if storage is a concern.

I had an 8 1/2" slider by DeWalt and quite liked it. It was really weight and accuracy that concerned me and I had a bigger 12" non-slider too. They weighed close to the same and were about equally bulky and awkward to move around.
 
#5 · (Edited by Moderator)
The only problem with smaller miter saws, is you will have to use the bevel function on boards over certain height can't be stood against the fence. That's a little harder to do.

I experienced this recently with a 10" miter cutting 4 1/4" baseboard.

That said, the saw was a Metabo 10" non slider (used to be Hitachi). IMO for $130 you can't beat it. My biggest knock is the dust collection is pretty much non existent.

A 12" miter saw will be the best choice IMO. Check out the Rousseau miter saw shroud.
 
#7 ·
Loren: Haven't seen that one before, but that's pretty slick how it folds up. Glad to hear your thoughts on a smaller slider. I've gotten the impression from others that the smallest they would go is 10", but with a slider I'm not sure of the drawback to an 8-1/2". Robert's point is well-taken, but I can spend a little more time to cut on the flat if needed since I'm just a hobbyist. Then again, perhaps I'm being naïve…

Thanks everyone for your thoughts.
 
#8 ·
If your concerned with space, the sliding miter saw takes more space verses the 12" miter chop saw. I have 12" miter chop saw because the sliding miter saw would stick out too far from the wall.

There's quite a few people started with using benchtop table saws and other benchtop tools with good results. Some have incorporated the benchtop equipment into their work benches and cabinets. Quite a few have put their stuff on casters so they can roll the tools out, use the tool, and roll them back out of the way. If you click on the 'Shops' tab on top of the page, you can browse through some of the LJ's "shops" to check how some have set up their spaces. This video may give you some ideas to a small shop layout
 
#13 · (Edited by Moderator)
My buddy purchased the Milwaukee 18v 7-1/4" SCMS (dual bevel). It has a decent capacity but more importantly it's compact, quiet, smooth, precise, and accurate. Did I mention compact, lightweight, cordless, and powerful? A blade that small has literally no deflection. I sold my big Dewalt 12" SCMS because I was going to get one also but then he offered to let me use his anytime I want to. Between the two of us it may get used once a month at the very most. In the past 20 years I can count on one hand the number of times I used the full the capacity of a 12" slider. I want/need accuracy WAY more than I need capacity. I have a table saw, two track saws, and a Festool MFT/3 setup for the big stuff.