You want solid wood for the bottoms also? What you using for drawer slides?

 

I've made drawers out of maple and ash and both work well. But I often use eastern white pine for drawer sides and backs, which is pretty traditional in North America as a secondary wood. While it's weaker than hardwoods it's very dimensionnally stable. There's probably no single "best" wood for this.
All the species you suggest would work, though I might tend toward elm, ash or maple rather than basswood (though I have little experience with it other than for carving, and looking at strength numbers it's no weaker than the pine I already mentioned). If ash is cheap go for it - it's extremely strong and generally fairly easy to work.
As for the thickness of the sides, if I had 5/4 wood I'd resaw it, but if I had 3/4 inch thick stock I'd just use it as is rather than planing it down.

 

I THINK I'll do solid for the bottoms. We'll see…

I'm planning on no slides. Just a piston fit on a web frame.

 

Thanks Jeremy - I do like the wood and sentiment of white pine. I know my local sawmill has pine - what if it's yellow pine? Is this alright? I feel like if the pine gets a couple dings on the inside drawer components - it just adds to the character.

Ash is an open pore wood is it not? If so, does this pose any problems in regards to looks or function?

Thanks guys

 

Also, does the soft, fuzzy pine pose problems or make it more difficult when cutting joinery?

 

Personally, I like yellow poplar. I make my drawer sides 5/8" thick. 3/4 looks wrong to me.

 

I would steer away from yellow pine unless it's old growth and quarter sawn. Plain sawn young growth SYP is noted for twisting, bowing, and warping.

 

I've seen drawer sides made of maple, ash, poplar, pine, and probably other woods. The British, I believe, traditionally used oak. Pine would probably be my last choice due to it's softness. If I understand the technique you plan to use, the drawer bottoms will ride on a wooden rail. That would be another reason to avoid pine, because a soft wood will wear faster. There is no reason to avoid an open grain wood like ash. Thickness of the sides depends somewhat on the size of the drawers, but 1/2" seems to be a standard thickness for dresser-sized drawers. I would re-think using solid wood on the bottoms. Thin plywood is easier and more stable.

 

If you use solid bottoms make sure they float and aren't glued in place.

 

I'm another fan of maple for drawer boxes … I have used 1/2" hard maple and like the way it finishes.

 

There's no problem at all in using solid wood for the bottoms, been done for centuries. Just make sure that, as TheFridge mentioned, they float, plus that the grain is oriented so that the bottoms expand and contract from front to back of the drawer (in other words, the grain on the bottom runs from side-to-side). The back of the drawer should be shorter than the front, so that the drawer bottom can slide in from the back. There should be a short slot in the bottom that gets a screw into the back piece.

 

I use Ash for my drawer sides…It is relatively cheap and work easily.

If I was making furniture that was going to be heritage quality, I would make solid wood bottoms.

For kids rooms which will get hard use, I might use Baltic Birch for drawers bottoms.I might also use a harder wood for the outside like oak or maple.

 

I like poplar for drawer sides. I think in most situations 1/2" drawer sides are about right, for larger drawers a 5/8" is good. Maple or birch iis another good choice although more costly. Poplar is cheap and usually free of defects and machines well. I re-saw it from 4/4 stock. Although My BORG has poplar in 1/2" thickness, and sometimes I go that route if I am in a hurry, it is quite expensive that way. I usually use plywood for the bottoms because it is fast and cheap and and I don't have to make wide glue ups and really no one cares what their drawer bottoms are made of as long as they are functional. That is unless I am making reproduction furniture. I have never used ash for drawer sides, but I don't see why it wouldn't work.

 

I have used poplar, elm. pecan, and maple for drawer sides and backs. Never pine. All of these have performed well.

I am inclined to say you are worrying too much over something that is not that critical.

 

Poplar or maple. 1/2" or 3/8".
I use 1/4" Baltic Birch for bottoms and they are loose.

 

Very good. Thank you all for your responses!

If I'm going with 1/2" sides - I think the best bang for the buck might be 5/4 lumber that I can resaw. There would be a lot less waist I think than starting with 4/4.