LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

phase converter for 3 phase 5-HP Delta table saw

1 reading
29K views 37 replies 17 participants last post by  makfin  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
Has anyone here used a phase converter?

I have a 3-phase, 5-hp delta 10" table saw. I am thinking of buying a phase converter so that I can run the table saw in my home workshop (single phase). I hope someone can give me some advise on this topic, including the set-up and type of converter (brand name).

-Thanks
 
#2 ·
I don't use phase converters but I have friends that do. The most recommended is a rotary phase converter. It runs off of single phase and generates the third leg of electricity to create three phase.

They work well but get an electrician for the hook-up.

An electrician will also be able to give you some good advice on getting one.
 
#3 ·
I have a rotary phase converter that can handle up to 15 HP, meaning I can run up to 3 tools at a time. I think you also need a transformer too, as the voltage on 3 phase is generally 550/560.

I spent around 6K for both units plus labour. I had a master electrician hook mine up.

It would be less $$$$ to change over the motor and switch!
 
#4 · (Edited by Moderator)
I own 2 phase converters, but only use one. it's a 5 - 7.5 HP version. It's an electronic version that kicks in the Third phase to start the motor (tablesaw.) and then drops off.

The saw then continues to run on 2 phase current, (220 Volts, really single phase on 2 wires). I've run this setup for about 25 years. So essentially you only get 2/3 of the rated HP of the motor.

It was first hooked up to planer that has a 5hp motor. I bought a new looking motor for $5.00 and figured that would be a lot cheaper that a new 5 hp motor.

I bought mine on eBay for $70.00 - $120.00. I don't remember the price.

I'm happy with the way it works. I burnt an earlier one out when the cord was laying in some wet sawdust and when I turned the saw on the power shorted out.

I hooked everything up myself. To reverse the motor you change any two of the three wires. So if your saw runs backward, you just reverse two of the leads.

On my magnetic switch on the saw the two hot wires are going through the coil contacts and the M line (manufactured power) goes through the switch.

I've been looking at making a rotary converter but haven't been able to pick up 10 HP 3 phase motor to make one. I had my eyes on one but the junk yard scrapped it before I grabbed it.

Chuck Bender a LJ'er uses a rotary version in his shop.
 
#7 ·
I did not get to finish my thought earlier because I got called off to breakfast.

Anyway, an electrician would be able to give you advice specific to your needs. The other guys are right in that you will only need a certain size for running just your tablesaw. But there are other things to consider such as hooking it up. As a remodeling contractor I suggest an electrician.

But another option may be to just replace the motor with a single phase. It will probably be less expensive.
 
#8 ·
I use a Kay Industries rotary phase converter. You should make sure you balance the voltages on the three legs so they are very close to each other. Voltages vary across the country and can affect the motor's performance. I used a buck/boost transformer in conjunction with the phase converter to get my voltages within 1 volt of each other. Some electronic controlled switches are quite sensitive to voltage fluctuations between the three legs.
Kay Industries rates their converters differently than most other manufacturers in that they rate their converters for the maximum size motor theat can be started at a time. For example a 7.5 HP converter is rated to start one motor at a time up to 7.5 HP. Once started the converter can then start another one. One can run up to about 18 to 21 HP at a time by starting the motors up one at a time. Other companies rate their converters at the maximum Hp allowed on the converter. Also, the general rule of thumb is that the heavier the converter the better the performance. Stay away from light weight converters. Mine weighs about 260 lbs.
Here is a link to Kay : http://kayind.com/tech_center/sizing_tables.html
 
#10 ·
Using 3-phase in a residential setting always makes me nervous. All it takes is that one leg dropping out for any reason and single phase the motor which can fry it in a heartbeat. Most recently I had a 3-phase refrigeration compressor lose the one leg all because the 3rd pole of the breaker failed….very expensive repair.
 
#13 ·
As Rick has suggested I would go with a VFD. The one you need is here
I have a 2hp VFD powering my '68 unisaw and I must say I love it. The installation was very easy and straight forward. Its as close to plug and play as you can get. I would most definately stay away from a static converter. They are hard on motors. If you decide to go with a rotary converter send me a PM and I can send you more info.
 
#14 · (Edited by Moderator)
One of the issues with modern VFDs is the requirement for VFD rated motors. Depending the cycles they are running at, they can blow out the insulation on older motors. You always run the risk of putting a lot of noise on the line that interferes with all kinds of electronic equipment. All of out modern electronic equipment; computers, electronic balllasts and VFDs raise problems with efficiency known as power factor. That is having the current our of sync with the voltage.

Everyone always says to get an electrician to wire it. I have been for 40 yrs+. My first choice would be to change the motor to 240 v single phase if it is an option as in this case and other 3 phase considerations are not a requirement. Especially in a residential enviornment.
 
#16 · (Edited by Moderator)
The static phase converter makes 3 phase power to run the motor at a set voltage. VFD, variable frequency drive will run the motor at a varying speed, voltage and frequency. One of the advantages of a VFD would be soft starting the motor with out the dramatic inrush current you see dimming the lights a bit. I wouldn't do it for that alone on a table saw starting without a load.
 
#17 ·
Well I feel that in this instance I have to agree 100% with Topamax's comment, when do you foresee to need 5HP in your home workshop? what size lumber do you expect to process there?
If 3HP will fit the bill there will be no detrimental effects on your saw, it will still outperform any smaller sized saw.
And as stated by others, Static Voltage converters only cheat the lack of the third phase, VFD's on the other hand have issues generating noise that could upset the neighbors when they watch TV or interfere with other electronics devices in your house. Rotary converters would be the way to go but are very expensive you would certainly save money by retrofitting a 3HP motor.
There those are my thoughts on this but in the end it is your choice, at least you have a fair amount of info to help you decide which route you will take, hey and when you do let us know and also how it persforms.
 
#18 ·
I would agree with Jerry and Topamax, if it's possible, change the motor to a single phase 240v. I've been an electrician for a few years and am currently going back to school for more training in industrial electical and we had an old Powermatic 3 phase drill press we wanted to sell but concluded it would be easier, economical, if we changed the motor out to a single phase. Plus if you do that, an industry in your area may buy the 3 phase motor from you.
 
#19 ·
thanks everyone for the insightful suggestions. I am convinced that a new 3HP, single phase motor is the way to go. I have to find someone who can buy my 5hp, 3phase motor. I hope the rewiring from 3phase to single phase will not be a problem. I tried to sell the saw on craigslist, but no interested buyers yet. I will certainly post my final decision - may not be soon though. well you can figure that out from name - lazyborn
 
#21 ·
I use a 15 HP rotary in my machine shop but as stated above, I would just get a single phase motor to replace your three phase 5 HP. If you had multiple machines needing 3 phase then it may make more sence to go with the converter but since you only have the one, it would prob be better to replace it. A 3 HP motoe should do well for you. The 3 HP on my Unisaw has plenty enough power to sling lumber into the concrete wall behind it!
 
#22 ·
I think everyone has this one covered for you….but I just wanted to add that we have 3 phase in our shop…for welding machines…etc….and there is a 5 and a 3 Hp set of band saws in here….of course they are for cutting metal. The 3 Hp gets most of the work as it is easier to set up and use…but as for guts…that lil 3HP cuts some big cuts just fine…..I don't think you really would find any use for the additional Hp on that saw…especially seeing the costs to acquire it…...
 
#24 ·
Thanks for the confidence in me Todd ;-)) I finally got used to people saying, "So you're Bob…......" when I met them. It was a bit embarrassing at first, but I got used to it. My reputation spread from WA to Boise. Looks like I need to watch it in MT now!!! :))