Get the Chisel you need and will use! I have a lot of chisels and just recently pick up with the Japanese dovetails,
should of got them sooner. Have usually used some Stanley Sweethearts and a collection of odds and ends, never really used my 2 Cherries much(just to pretty). Have a set of Narex Mortise chisels that meet all my need for that purpose but would really like to try out one of them old English Pig Stickers!
To start all over it would be the Veritas PMV-11s and a set of Japanese Dovetails. (Maybe the Veritas Mortise too)

 

I did with the LN chisels. No regrets.

 

just get the set of 7 narex and go from there and upgrade when you wear those out http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=67707&cat=1,41504

 

Chisels have been a money pit for me. I have spent way too much on these things! I have discarded (given away) several sets over the years, but still have 4 complete sets (two butt sets, one bench set, one mortising set).

So, I started to keep track of what I actually use AND try to make frugal use of what I have. That is, I try to use the LEAST number of chisels from my set. So far, the results have been only a little surprising.

I use a 1/2" Sweetheart most of all. Primarily for dovetails, but also for general cleanup of minor corner and surface anomalies. Used to was that I grabbed whatever chisel was sharp - which eventually resulted in no sharp chisels and an evening of sharpening, and confusion. Now, I find that sticking to the 1/2" allows me to do 2/3 of what I need to do with just that one chisel.

Next up is a 1/4" Iles mortising chisel, for cleaning out mortises. Since almost everything I do is done with 4/4 boards, tenons are usually 1/4" thick.

Then, the 1/4" Sweetheart, for getting into tight spots.

Then, I use a wide chisel for cleaning up both the sides of mortises and tenon cheeks (I don't own a good tenon plane, but should). I used to use a 1" for this, but upon reflection now (usually) use a 3/4". Depending on the type of wood I'm working, I might use either the Sweetheart OR the Iles mortising; go figure. BUT, I suspect that these needs would be better served by a combination of a good shoulder plane and a wide-ish paring chisel.

Since I've started paying attention, I have not used my various butt chisels at all. I do occasionally use a specific bench or mortising chisel of a size exactly matched to an unusually sized component (e.g., a 3/8" mortise and tenon).

I think the reality is that I could do everything I need to with 1/2" bench, 1/4" bench and mortising, 3/4" paring chisel.

All the others are an expensive luxury that I probably don't really need.

 

Thanks, folks, for answers.

I'm actually looking to replace/retire a set of Narex bench chisels. In addition, I've been very impressed with the Japanese chisels someone let me try.

Like jdmaher, I'm pretty sure I use a 1/2" chisel the most. So, I've already set my eyes on a 12mm Iyoroi Blue Steel Chisel, from Gramercy (Tools for Working Wood). Being pretty much a noob, however, I'm not sure where to go next. Jdmaher makes a pretty good argument for his selection. I'll have to think about it.

Again, thanks!

 

https://wnwoodworkingschool.com/product-category/hand-tools/chisels/

HTH

 

I find I use a wide chisel quite a lot. One
of my favorites is a Japan chisel about
1-3/8" wide. It's useful for chopping
thin pieces to size, paring tenons and
other things. The short blade gets my
fingers close to the work.

My Japan chisels are similar to the basic
ones Lee Valley sells. I have some Barr
chisels too, which are very nice to use
and stay sharp a long time.