Even though this is an old thread, it's one that seems to resurface in a lot of forums on a regular basis. I'm getting ready to pipe my shop that I moved to last fall, and am debating this issue from the cost, safety and durability perspectives. I know several guys that run PVC and most have had no problems. I know one guy who ran the rapidair system and couldn't get it to stop leaking, though that could very well be an installation issue. I asked him if he used a plastic tubing cutter (frequently called a PEX cutter and cuts the tubing square with no burrs). The blank look on his face was all the answer I needed.
Now - having said all that, and based on 40 yrs of engineering and building (everything from cars to machinery to houses), here's my 2 cents worth:
I've seen copper systems and worked with black pipe systems (just installed 500 lf of it in a machine shop last fall). I've worked with all of these materials extensively. I was using the nylon hose/push connect (industrial version) on manufacturing equipment in the early '80's. It was "new" then, but was a lot more versatile than hard lines, more durable than rubber. I pulled some SCH 80 PVC out of that machine shop, and it is one of the options up for consideration at this time also. And since I am one of the many Americans "underemployed" by the economy, cost is a serious consideration.
The most important consideration on putting in any system other than stock length rubber hose (come on now, who would really do that?) is your skill level. If you are Picasso with a wood chisel but aren't sure what a tubing cutter or crescent wrench is, call in a buddy that is. No matter what type of system you install, a sloppy job will be a continuous headache. And this is not the place to learn self-taught pipefitting or PVC plumbing.
Rigid pipe near the ceiling with a steady (1/8/lf) slope to a water drain is best approach to a trouble free system, period. Some slope it back to the compressor, I find it works best to slope away from the compressor. Turn all your Tees up - come off the top of the pipe and leave the condensation in the main line (to drain down to the water trap at the end). Support the pipe adequately to keep the drainage working. Buy a 25' section of rubber hose (at least 1/2" ID), coil it up on the concrete floor and hook one end to the compressor, the other to a good quality water/oil filter BEFORE it goes into the piping. The coiled up pipe on the concrete acts like a condenser and will allow the filter to remove most of the water and oil from the air.
THE CHOICES
PVC SCH 40 - Pro's: cheapest solution. Cons: Like copper, all PVC is not alike. Just because it's white and in the rack at the box store doesn't mean that it's good quality ore even schedule 40. DVW is also white and in those racks, but it's a lot thinner and lower rated. Some fittings will interchange but again, are not equal. Considerations: Run it up to the ceiling out of harm's way. Anchor it every 4-5' and immediately before a hose connection. If you can solder (or know someone who can) buy copper shower head elbows to anchor your hose connections. They are threaded on 1 end, slip (solder) on the other and have 2 ears to screw to the wall or ceiling. Don't screw them to drywall, it will give when you plug & unplug the hose, leading to an eventual failure of the PVC just above the fitting.
PVC schedule 80. Double everything of SCH 40 except cost - that's triple. I priced out the fittings for my 2 bay shop system (I scavenged the pipe) at a local plumbing supply where I can buy wholesale. $80 (which is why I've not made a decision yet).
Black Piipe. The choice of most industries.Pros: cheapest of the hard pipe, readily available most everywhere.Cons: .Harder to work with, you will need a threading die and a pipe vise. Forget the teflon tape, you need the liquid teflon for this stuff. As this stuff is a low tech, mass produced product, expect some fittings with pin holes. Considerations - Check it carefully when you buy it, if it's not clean inside then it never will be. Buy this at a plumbing supply house, not a box store. Keep the water out of it and it will last forever.
Galvanized Pipe. Double everything of the Black Pipe. Overkill unless you are running it outside or in a very wet environment.
Copper - Pros: Easier than Black Pipe, at least twice the price but you don't need the threading equipment. Use type L, use the soft grades (read the printing on the pipes - I think L is the red print). You may have to get this at the plumbing supply also. Pre-soldered fittings work great if you don't know how to solder, but you will pay dearly for them.
PEX - Pro's - easy to work with, like the nylon, if you use the right tools. Cons - you need special tools to cut and crimp. If you use this, avoid the coils and use the rigid pipe. There are different grades of PEX - type tubing (not just colors). You may want to do some research on these before going this route. I have read that there is a PEX -type tubing that is rated for air use, but haven't seen any. Even though I have all the tools and ti's probably the cheapest, I am still researching it.
Rubber hose - Pros: easiest solution for the average non-pipefitter/welder/plumber. Cons: any air hose over 10 is a problem and if you use cheap (box stores/HF) air hose, it is at best a temporary solution. If you are determined to go this route, go to McMaster Carr and buy bulk hose and fittings.
Pre-made systems: RapidAir (nylon tubing), GaragePak (aluminum tubing). Probably the easiest for the d-i-y guy with a limited knowledge of pipefitting/plumbing. They are pricey ($200-$500) but take all of the unknowns out of the process.
See why it's such a hard decision?