LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

The best chisels you can buy at a grocery store

30K views 22 replies 16 participants last post by  GregoryH  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
WorkZONE - 4 Piece Chisel set (Rating: 4)

If you follow Paul Sellers blogs or videos at all, you've heard him mention that discount grocery store chain Aldi carries chisels from time to time - and in his opinion they are quite good. Unfortunately these have not been made available in North America. That is until a few months ago.

Based on the fact Paul raves about these chisels many times over, there is an Aldi store less than 3 miles from my home, and the 4 piece set costs me $7.49 with tax, I decided to grab them. I wanted to put them through their paces a bit before passing judgement. I have used these exclusively for the past 2 months or so. I only use hand tools in my work so they got quite a work out

Initial Impressions

Not good. The handles are an atrocity in my opinion.They are way over varnished, hooped for no reason, about an inch too long, and a really odd shape. As you can see by the last picture, I fixed that problem with a lathe and some copper pipe. Here is one side by side with my wood river chisels:

Image


They are metric. Not a big deal when it comes to chisels in my opinion.

Initial Sharpening

I was pleasantly surprised here. First a word of caution. Most chisels need to be honed before use, but these are perhaps the dullest chisels I have used right out of the package. If you don't have a way to sharpen, don't expect to use these. I had budgeted some serious time and wear and tear on my stones. After all these are 7 dollar a set chisels sold in a grocery store. Come to find out, the backs all had a slight hollow. This made flattening a breeze. From out of the package to surgical sharp was roughly 5 minutes a chisel.

Image


Use

I kept looking for a reason to hate on these chisels. I was skeptical from the moment I brought them home. How can a 7 dollar set of CR-V chisels be worth using for anything other than opening paint cans? Well they never let me down. No, these are not PM-V11, they will not hold an edge for 3 months. However edge retention was better than I expected. Because these are CR-V, they are really easy to bring back to the bleeding edge of sharpness. Once they feel the slightest bit dull, drag them over a strop twice and you are good to go.

In the few months of use, I have not returned these to a stone since the initial honing. Flexcut gold and some leather is all it has taken to keep these in business.

Action shots:

Chopping out some waste (oak). The bevels are a bit steep, but fit close enough (this is a 10 degree dovetail)

Image


Nice clean pin board (oak)

Image


Very clean end grain paring. Lots of control, no blowout

Image


So after these convinced me they were more than glue scrapers, I decided to remove the horrible ash handles and replace them. If you are in an Aldi store and see these, grab them.

Image
 

Attachments

#5 · (Edited by Moderator)
I'm a Paul Sellers fan,

The blog and his YouTube videos. Paul is a down to earth easy going, patient and clear instructor, and he is an advocate of "the everyman woodworker." Paul has driven up the Ebay prices by advocating for the older gems in handtools. He was pretty excited to have negotiated with Aldis to have his favorite "inexpensive" quality chisel that he found while shopping at Aldis in England made available in the USA. He did his quality checks and found the chisels sold in England to be what Lumberjoe is describing.

If you check out his blog and you value handtools you will find a thread on these chisels that he convinced Aldis to sell in his second home, the USA. Paul lived and taught in Texas for awhile.

Do yourself and Paul a favor (as I accidentally did) and subscribe to his YouTube channel, and his blog, which allows him to produce more internet videos. (and get a subsistence?)

Paul is also a Lumberjock but at this time is busy with his woodworking program.
 
#10 · (Edited by Moderator)
I have a similar set as well. I've been a Habor Frieght buyer for many years.

The chisels at Aldis are Chrome Vanadium Steel as Noted in in this great review. Grizzly is selling Chrome V chisels at reasonable price last time I looked.

If you can validate CR V steel you might have an ok set.

You can check out Pauls blog on this if you like.


This is the You Tube video on the chisels.

Disclaimer: I'm just a fan of this great teacher.
 
#11 · (Edited by Moderator)
I have a similar set as well. I've been a Habor Frieght buyer for many years.

The chisels at aldis are Chrome Vandium Steel as Noted in in this great review. Grizzly is selling Chrome V chisels at reasonable price last time I looked.

If you can validate CR V steel you might have an ok set.

http://lumberjocks.com/reviews/5858#comment-2458858

Here is the YouTube video.

My disclaimer: I just think Paul is a great teacher, your opinions may vary.
 
#12 · (Edited by Moderator)
I have the same chisels and they work great. Mine came reasonably sharpened out of the package.

A note of caution: Some of the chisels had the grain in the handle going in crocked directions to an extent that it looked loke a failure waiting to happen. Just leafed through the pile and picked the straightest ones.

The new handles you made look fab! Thanks for sharing your thoughts
 
#13 · (Edited by Moderator)
I have a similar set as well. I ve been a Habor Frieght buyer for many years.

The chisels at aldis are Chrome Vandium Steel as Noted in in this great review. Grizzly is selling Chrome V chisels at reasonable price last time I looked.

If you can validate CR V steel you might have an ok set.

http://lumberjocks.com/reviews/5858#comment-2458858

Here is the YouTube video.

My disclaimer: I just think Paul is a great teacher, your opinions may vary.

- DocSavage45
Yea I shop at HF some times but I try to be very careful of what I get.
I have seen all of Paul's Videos and read most of his Blog as well , If I could afford a Trip to the UK I would take one of his classes , if he could put up with a hand tool Dummy like me.
 
#15 · (Edited by Moderator)
Good review. HF has a set for about the same price. I bought them for times when I don't want to damage my better set. The handles are an abomination but after I sharpened them I was surprised at how well they performed.

The steel is soft so you can flatten and sharpen them very fast but you will have to hone more often if you use them a lot.

I don't use them a lot but for under $10 I'm glad I have them when I need them.
 
#17 · (Edited by Moderator)
I also have 2 sets of Harbor Freight chisels - the wood handled ones and the plastic handled ones.

The wood handled ones are terrible IMO. Edge retention is non-existent. I use them when I need metal wedges.

The plastic handled ones aren't too bad, but not great. Those are what I use when I am all but certain I'll damage an edge. They will hold and edge for a little while and can do things a chisel should do

The WorkZone (Aldi) bench chisels actually perform like a proper woodworking bench chisel should. You can aggressively pound it through a full drawer of pins and tails, then take it straight to delicate end grain paring without stopping off at the stones first.