LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

Staircase drawers -are they safe or not?

8.6K views 33 replies 13 participants last post by  MiniMe  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
I was looking for ideas and DIY guides on who to build staircase drawers and I came across this thread
https://forum.canadianwoodworking.com/forum/home-improvements/home-improvements-aa/1068765-drawers-in-stair-risers

which ended in a fight :)) so no I am not looking for that but I am looking for some feedback on whether it is safe of not to build, more exactly about affecting the structural integrity of the steps (they could sag if the raiser is not there anymore

There is tons of examples here https://www.pinterest.ca/search/my_pins/?q=stair%20drawers

I am having the hardwood floor installed in an old house, the plan is to add 3/8" plywood on top of the existing diagonal boards running over the joists.
The engineered hardwood floor I am looking at is 3/4" so this could raise the floor with almost 1".
My raisers are 8"x44" and I have 4 of them (raised bungalow) and the plan is to add drawers for the middle ones in order to eliminate the clutter we have at the entrance with everybody leaving their shoes there

So are these safe?
and the golden question that the pro ask "Are they code ? "
 
#2 ·
There is no code I know of that specifically discusses drawers in risers…. So, that is a matter for the local building office and the inspector who comes to inspect! They are supposed to be there to help home owners wiht projects like this. Wouldn't hurt to reach out?

Lot of info will go into deciding whether they are safe or not.

First, would be stair size… and drawer size. Next, would be there underlying construction of the stairs. Without that info, it would be nearly impossible to answer your question.
 
#4 ·
I have never built stairs before but is your question basically whether you can make the step or tread strong enough if it is only supported on the sides? That would seem to be a function of width and thickness of the tread.

Personally, I like the idea having the tread hinged to open to make a compartment or box. That would seem to be simpler to do and might also be bigger because you do not have the drawer slides, sides and bottoms taking up space. You can also make the compartments deeper than the rise of each step themselves.
 
#5 · (Edited by Moderator)
Image


I can't tell you about codes. But we have three drawers in our steps. Installed when the steps were built in the 1930's or 40's. The treads are 3/4" oak, about 3' wide. They sit on wood runners, no fancy modern guides. So after 80 or 90 years, and four generations of my family being raised here, including our four kids, the steps have not collapsed under the daily traffic, and there were no codes or inspections when built. Curious as to why you are adding the plywood. Our 3/4 oak is nailed to the 3/4 diagonal pine.
 

Attachments

#7 ·
It is my opinion that no matter how thick the treads are, they will sag when weight is put on them. They may sag ever so slightly that a drawer would bind at the top edge. Of course, no weight would be on the tread when the drawer was in use, so maybe it is not too bad an idea. If someone were standing on that particular tread when trying to open the drawer under that tread, it may sag enough to keep the drawer from opening easily. Wood today is not as strong as the first growth wood used years ago. As one responder noted, a hinged door may be better than a drawer.
 
#9 ·
Yeah probably adding a support vertical board in the middle under the step could solve any problems related to sagging BUT it will force me to build two drawers instead of one AND two sets of rails :-(

re: why subfloor over diagonal boards
the house is 60Y+ old and I want to make sure there will be no sounds when this new engineered floor will be installed (7" or 8" wide board, 7' long each)
https://estaparket.eu/product/16003/ or https://www.coswick.com/product/aqua-white/
 
#15 ·
I wonder how stiff the engineered flooring is? My assumption is not very, since it is designed to be laid on top of subfloor. I think that the subflooring is usually 3/4" thick with whatever the standard joist spacing is for flooring (12-16"?). So using the sagulator, a 1" piece of plywood 44" wide with basically no riser will sag 0.10" with 300 lb center load. I would guess that is not to code. The design of Jon's step drawers shown above appears to reduce that span on his from about 36" to 18". it may also have some support from the approximately 1" strip above the drawer. In your case, that might bring the sag down to an acceptable level but you would have to ask the local inspector whether it meets code.
 
#18 ·
Is there one or two central stringers? If there's only one, maybe two narrow drawers per riser would help preserve the integrity of the stairs. 44" is pretty wide so I imagine you could fit something close to 15 or 16" wide in there. Tough to say without seeing exactly what you have. Sounds like a neat idea though
 
#19 ·
While this is a unique way to use what looks like wasted space. The real issue is one of safety. Can you guarantee no one will ever leave one of those drawers partially open when somebody else is at the top of those stairs. What happens when they start down those stairs unaware of that partially open drawer.
 
#20 ·
I lived in South Bend , IN, back in early 70s, and refubed a nice home on the ST.Joe just above notre dame.
three story, awesome house, total refurb, brought it back to its original flavor, had to make so many moldings and ext trim pcs. and painting was the nightmare.
with that said ,the built ins were off the chart, all three sets of stairs had multiple drawers and the large ornate entry stairs had wall cabinet displays, it was at that time the first time i'd seen stairs with drawers, but once i finished the place and had an open house, found from many other refurbers and home owners they too had almost every inch of stair, nooks and crannies with drawers, cabinets ,displays ect.

don't recall any complaining of accidents or possibility of an accident, fall intended or otherwise, i get the worrisome thoughts, but one can also get run over setting at a bus stop. can't they probably happens more than a drawer being left open on stairs.
rj in az
 
#23 ·
Our house has two sets of stairs between the upper and lower floors. I think of them first and foremost as a means of escaping a fire. I would not add the risk of there being an open drawer at the worst possible moment. Call me paranoid, but I learned a lot from my brother-in-law who was a fire chief for many years.
 
#24 ·
I think two sets of stairs were the norm when a house had residents and "the help". I grew up in a house where the third floor was for service persons. The floors were wide plank pine where other floors were oak. A call box was on the hall wall to indicate what room needed service or door bell. The kitchen had a call box too. I am not sure if the resident of the house went there much either. Carriage house had a bedroom above for the caretaker there too.
 
#26 · (Edited by Moderator)
Why do you need drawers in your stairs? What do you want to put in them? The drawers would be shallow and short front to back.
I read the post on the Canada forum and one idea was posted that sounded like a better idea and that was to have the tread hinged to lift up rather than using a drawer. That way, you don't compromise the integrity of the staircase and remove any danger of an accident. Problem solved.