LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

Benchtop vs Full-size Jointer

17K views 19 replies 19 participants last post by  pontic  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
I'm a hobby woodworker looking at expanding my shop and capabilities, and I'd like to buy a general purpose jointer. What are your thoughts on something like the Wahuda 8" jointer? https://www.wahudatools.com/product-p/50180cc-whd.htm

It seems like it might be a bit cheesy and too short, but the price is attractive. Would I be better off to bite the bullet and get something like an 8" Grizzly with a spiral cutter head, or would that be unnecessary overkill for a weekend woodworker? I probably won't need to ever joint boards over 8' long, with 3-6' being more likely.

Also, is it worth the extra money to get an 8" model? It seems that would be the case for flattening cupped boards.

Any guidance or experience would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks!
 
#2 ·
Jumping up to an 8" jointer is a big step, size, weight and money-wise. I'd LOVE one, but can't afford it, size-wise, weight-wise or money-wise.

I do have an old Rockwell/Delta cast iron 4" jointer gifted to me by my grandfather that is only suited for small projects under 3' in length and narrower than the 4" capacity. It's extremely handy for projects of smaller scale so for larger boards, I've either gone with a planer sled with shims under the high areas or I've used a router sled. They are both a bit of a pain to use, but there is a tremendous amount of youtube videos and magazine articles devoted to getting around not having a wide jointer at your disposal.

I don't have any experience about the particular jointer you mentioned, but I do know that running long boards over short jointer wings often leads to boards that aren't nearly flat along the entire edge. When I first got the tool, I messed up quite a bit of lumber chasing flatness, especially when there is a bow along the length of the board and it isn't supported.

Hope my comments are helpful.
 
#3 ·
i started with a table top model years ago but quickly realized it was not going to do what i needed,it was just too short to handle long boards.i do a lot of furniture but if you mostly do short pieces under 4' it might be fine.a 6" jointer might work it's what ive got now and it does the job but id like to upgrade to a 8".
 
#4 ·
Dive into a 6" model. You will quickly outgrow the desktop model unless all you do is small boxes, birdhouses and the like. The 6" models can be found cheaply on Craigslist. I got one and thought I would move to an 8" soon after. seven years later, still have the 6". My dream is to find an old 12" jointer, but we will see. I'm in no hurry.
 
#6 · (Edited by Moderator)
Are you doing bench top size or full size projects? That will decide what jointer you need. A micro jointer may work if you only plan to build cutting boards and boxes. It sure won't joint a 6-8' long board without significant struggles.

I say get a full sized 8" jointer. Cry once and let your woodworking capabilities expand as needed. I wouldn't limit myself to only small projects only.
 
#7 · (Edited by Moderator)
The Wahuda has less than half the cutterheads of a typical stationary Jointer like any of the Grizzly models. It is only a 2" cylinder and in my opinion under powered. I wouldn't buy a benchtop jointer for myself but you may be completely happy with it. If you can swing it I'd look the G0656X as the 8" spiral cutterhead entry point but the G0490X would be my likely choice if I were buying an 8". I personally have a 12" Grizzly G0690X which is now discontinued. Just buy the biggest jointer you can afford now or save up and wait a little longer to get what you really want.
 
#8 ·
My advice, go with 8" jointer, new or used. Can't do better than Grizzly for the money. Nothing wrong with straight knives. Love my Shopfox equivalent of the 8" Grizzly. Don't mind sharpening/setting knives. In fact I enjoy it. Recently jointed a lot of Birdseye maple with no tear out.
 
#9 ·
I would think you are asking the wrong question maybe. Asking does anyone have a Cutech jointer near (your zip code, or area) Go look at one in action, and see if it will do what you want done.

If you buy based on what others think, and ends up you don't think the same, I do know one truth here. Table top tools DO NOT hold their value worth a darn, so you are gonna take an expensive bath if it turns out you want to flip it to buy a full size, which does hold value better, brand name not important.
 
#12 ·
Thanks everyone! I really appreciate the thoughtful and detailed responses. I think I'm going to do a bit of re-organizing in my shop and see if I can fit a full-size 8" jointer. It sounds like I'll probably regret purchasing a bench-top model unless dictated by a space limitation and a full-size model will be worth the money in the long run.
 
#18 ·
for small projects the small table top is great, but once you start joint boards thirty inches or longer, your better off with a the longer bed, even if only if it's only a 6" jointer. I do use a Grizzly G1531 6"x80" edge belt sanders for a lot of jointing, a nice multi function machine (sanding, squaring edges and jointing).

Grizzly G0813, 6Ă—48 is $625 plus shipping. if your jointing boards over 5', then I like the 70" or longer beds.