Blemishes/spots in arm r seal finish

Pictures would help. No idea what you’re describing.

I did have pictures in there. Not sure what happened. Will repost

Adding more finish will not solve the problem. It’s hard to tell, but it looks like the finish is indeed wearing away in those spots, though I’m skeptical of that as an explanation because I don’t see scratches or what I’d expect to see if it were wearing away due to use. It could be the angle and the light that’s preventing me from seeing those.

Arm-R-Seal is not a finish you can just seamlessly blend the new with the old, unfortunately. It builds up in distinct, separate layers, unlike something like lacquer which is pretty homogeneous throughout and can thus be repaired quite easily.

I looked back at your original post of the project and you mentioned rubbing the finish out too much causing discoloration along with “soapy” spots that required “heavy sanding”. Are these the same spots? Maybe those spots are just a lot thinner than the rest and have worn quicker??

Nice looking table, though.

Is that wear from the top down through the clear coat? It looks more like haze from beneath the finish in those pics.

-- "You know, I'm such a great driver, it's incomprehensible that they took my license away." --Vince Ricardo

To see if it’s on the surface or beneath the surface, wipe the table top down with mineral spirits. If the problem areas go away until the MS dries, you’ll know all you need to do is coat it with finish (poly or whatever).

To see if it’s on the surface or beneath the surface, wipe the table top down with mineral spirits. If the problem areas go away until the MS dries, you’ll know all you need to do is coat it with finish (poly or whatever). As mentioned, arm r seal is not a finish.

- Fthis

No, Arm-R-Seal definitely is a finish. Read Jonah’s complete sentence. He didn’t say it’s not a finish, he said it’s not a finish that will blend easily with existing layers, like lacquer and shellac. It can be done, but it will take a lot of know how.

-- Knowledge is not skill. Knowledge plus ten thousand times is skill. -- Shinichi Suzuki

I have a couple of desks with large tops that are finished with Arm-R-Seal. The only time I’ve seen light discoloring like this on walnut was when I didn’t get all of the glue wiped off and sanded out before I started applying Arm-R-Seal. Any chance you got something on the raw wood that sealed it off in those places? Still, I would expect to see that kind of discoloration immediately, not after a year.

-- Earl "I'm a pessamist - generally that increases the chance that things will turn out better than expected"

To see if it’s on the surface or beneath the surface, wipe the table top down with mineral spirits. If the problem areas go away until the MS dries, you’ll know all you need to do is coat it with finish (poly or whatever). As mentioned, arm r seal is not a finish.

- Fthis

No, Arm-R-Seal definitely is a finish.

I edited right after submitting. I wasn’t thinking about their top coat.

Thanks for the responses. I don’t recall if it’s he same spots that were cloudy when I first finished it. Too long ago. A couple questions:

Is that wear from the top down through the clear coat? It looks more like haze from beneath the finish in those pics.

- Ripper70

What would cause haze from below?

To see if it’s on the surface or beneath the surface, wipe the table top down with mineral spirits. If the problem areas go away until the MS dries, you’ll know all you need to do is coat it with finish (poly or whatever). As mentioned, arm r seal is not a finish.

- Fthis

No, Arm-R-Seal definitely is a finish. Read Jonah’s complete sentence. He didn’t say it’s not a finish, he said it’s not a finish that will blend easily with existing layers, like lacquer and shellac. It can be done, but it will take a lot of know how.

- Rich

Hmmm… I have limited know how. Would sanding and doing new coats over the whole thing work or do I need to fully strip it down. When I look closely and run my hand on it it doesn’t look or feel like he finish is rubbed through but maybe I just don’t know what to look for.

I have a couple of desks with large tops that are finished with Arm-R-Seal. The only time I ve seen light discoloring like this on walnut was when I didn t get all of the glue wiped off and sanded out before I started applying Arm-R-Seal. Any chance you got something on the raw wood that sealed it off in those places? Still, I would expect to see that kind of discoloration immediately, not after a year.

- EarlS

I can’t think of anything. It’s nowhere near a glue line and I can’t think of what else would have gotten on it.

Hard to see the quality or porosity of surface finish?

One observation:
discoloration is limited to softer, more porous areas, and does not effect the harder annual rings?

On a flat sawn board like that one shown, it is possible to have scalloping or dishing into the softer wood; especially when using ROS. This makes for uneven top coat thickness, and maybe even spots near rings/ridges with limited top coat that could allow contamination to penetrate under finish. If you used a sanding sealer under the ArmRSeal, then the staining could be non-uniformity in sanding sealer that has become apparent thanks to changes in moisture.

Is there any indication that surface was scraped, damaged, or has exposed grain?
+1 – wipe it down with mineral spirits: does it change stain color?
If it is restored with MS, then additional top coating should fix issue.

The color change appears to almost be bleached. Is there open grain showing around the stained areas, where some cleaning agent has permeated to wood?
Applying MS in this condition might have some MS penetrate and only partially change the color. If this happens, then need to sand off old finish, and redo entire top.

Best Luck!

-- I'm an engineer not a woodworker, but I can randomly find useful tools and furniture inside a pile of lumber!