Randy,
You spark a good topic here. Personally, I think the fundamental issue is, or perhaps should be, how much satisfaction I get from using the tool. After all, as long as the blade goes round, it will cut wood. And many a fine project has been built with tools bordering on the primitive. But it isn't much fun.
Ultimately, I suppose it depends on what you want to do with the saw, and your expectations. Thirty years ago I replaced my Craftsman contractors saw because every time I used it it annoyed me in one way or another: either underpowered, or the terrible fence, or a miter that "almost" was OK, kickbacks. etc. etc. I replaced it thirty years ago with a new Delta Beaver cabinet saw (Canadian Unisaw) and with the Incra TS fence it still makes me smile with satisfaction every time I flip the switch. It works like the Lexus it has always been. Thirty years of that warm feeling, not to mention never a problem, is worth a lot. At least to me. I really hate to deal with a tool that I have doubts about. But then, perhaps I'm just getting old and intolerant. LOL
Roger
You spark a good topic here. Personally, I think the fundamental issue is, or perhaps should be, how much satisfaction I get from using the tool. After all, as long as the blade goes round, it will cut wood. And many a fine project has been built with tools bordering on the primitive. But it isn't much fun.
Ultimately, I suppose it depends on what you want to do with the saw, and your expectations. Thirty years ago I replaced my Craftsman contractors saw because every time I used it it annoyed me in one way or another: either underpowered, or the terrible fence, or a miter that "almost" was OK, kickbacks. etc. etc. I replaced it thirty years ago with a new Delta Beaver cabinet saw (Canadian Unisaw) and with the Incra TS fence it still makes me smile with satisfaction every time I flip the switch. It works like the Lexus it has always been. Thirty years of that warm feeling, not to mention never a problem, is worth a lot. At least to me. I really hate to deal with a tool that I have doubts about. But then, perhaps I'm just getting old and intolerant. LOL
Roger