Just shorten the bench up maybe?Dovetail Saga - Dovetail Number Two
Went a little past the mark on the tails on this one.
![]()
Yikes! Looks a little bit jagged on the back side - that's the side it's more difficult to keep an eye on.
![]()
Uh oh! Big mistake - back to the lumber yard to fetch more wood to fix this mistake. Just a teeny bit discouraging.
![]()
Hi TheFridge - yep! I ended up abandoning the dovetail joints on this project (see next few posts - I just added them - finally got caught up on posting progress on this project, whew!) I am going to do rabbet joints and put some 5/16" oak dowels in the joints for appearance and added strength (sheer strength too). I made some arrows a long time ago with the oak dowels - but never got to fletching them because they warped so much, so I am going to use them to make dowels for my joints on this project. They should look nice after putting a bit of finish on the wood.Dovetail Saga - Dovetail Number Two
Went a little past the mark on the tails on this one.
![]()
Yikes! Looks a little bit jagged on the back side - that's the side it's more difficult to keep an eye on.
![]()
Uh oh! Big mistake - back to the lumber yard to fetch more wood to fix this mistake. Just a teeny bit discouraging.
![]()
Rod, despite the over cut, those dovetails were looking good. I'm thinking you should incorporate them into your repertoire. If not on the bench, then in a first build.Dovetail Saga - Dovetail Number Two
Went a little past the mark on the tails on this one.
![]()
Yikes! Looks a little bit jagged on the back side - that's the side it's more difficult to keep an eye on.
![]()
Uh oh! Big mistake - back to the lumber yard to fetch more wood to fix this mistake. Just a teeny bit discouraging.
![]()
Thanks Buckethead! Thank you for the encouragement. Dovetails are immensely fascinating. I really like the big ones like these. And I really love this southern yellow pine! What a great wood. For some reason I like the resinous parts the best. I guess I like the smell of turpentine, LOL! I am really happy with the outcome of the first two upright assemblies that constitute the first saw bench/saw horse (the ones that I did the rabbet joints on instead of these dovetails). I am getting ready to attach the feet to the first one and then on to the second one. Then I'll solicit the help of a friend and move the 4-1/2" slab down to the garage and begin to plane the top flat (then I will even up the bottom boards) - or perhaps do the bottom of the slab first and then the top? I feel confident that if I take my time and cut the tails and pins proud, then trim them to fit that I can make a decent dovetail more like the very first one that I did. Thanks again for your kind words.Dovetail Saga - Dovetail Number Two
Went a little past the mark on the tails on this one.
![]()
Yikes! Looks a little bit jagged on the back side - that's the side it's more difficult to keep an eye on.
![]()
Uh oh! Big mistake - back to the lumber yard to fetch more wood to fix this mistake. Just a teeny bit discouraging.
![]()
Sharp tool are a must, especially with softwoods, where the fibers tend to compress instead of shear if the tool is getting dull. I'd try making a dove tail guide and using a marking knife if you haven't.Dovetail Saga - Dovetail Number Three
Tails of dovetail number three. Middle is humped up, but at least it's not cut past the mark like the ends are.
![]()
Starting to look sloppy. I'm not sure if I was getting tired or what here. Good picture though - the camera decided to focus on the boxes and stuff in the background.
![]()
Dovetail number three I think - Whoa! Little bit of a gap there dude!
![]()
And the view from the end - Wow, too much space in between the parts. I know what happened though. The first dovetail, I was very cautious (because I had never done one before) and I ended up trimming and paring a lot to make it fit (apparently that is what you are supposed to do - but it seemed like a LOT of work - but probably because I hadn't sharpened my chisels and I wasn't using them on these dovetails - not good.)
![]()
TheFridge - you are so right. I was SO being lazy and not using a chisel. I did eventually buy a 5/8" Kobalt chisel a couple nights ago. Sharpened that baby up tonight after I got off work (I am actually working on making some dado cuts on my uprights for my stretchers - and I am taking my time with my saw cuts and then knocking out small chunks of waste at a time with the chisel. It is sharp enough to easily clean up the bottom of the dado too). I had thought about making a galvanized metal template for my dovetails, and next time I will do that. It makes marking the tails quicker and easier. At least they are the same that way.Dovetail Saga - Dovetail Number Three
Tails of dovetail number three. Middle is humped up, but at least it's not cut past the mark like the ends are.
![]()
Starting to look sloppy. I'm not sure if I was getting tired or what here. Good picture though - the camera decided to focus on the boxes and stuff in the background.
![]()
Dovetail number three I think - Whoa! Little bit of a gap there dude!
![]()
And the view from the end - Wow, too much space in between the parts. I know what happened though. The first dovetail, I was very cautious (because I had never done one before) and I ended up trimming and paring a lot to make it fit (apparently that is what you are supposed to do - but it seemed like a LOT of work - but probably because I hadn't sharpened my chisels and I wasn't using them on these dovetails - not good.)
![]()
The last picture is very telling. I cannot achieve those results yet. It is a lot of technique… but probably has to do with my lack of proper layout, and accurate lines to begin with.Transition from Dovetails to Rabbet Joints
If thy dovetail offend thee, cut it off!
![]()
I decided to not use these dovetails that I have been practicing on. I read on two different articles that you should practice on scrap wood and not on your project (which is what I have been doing). Plus, I want the joints to reflect a similar quality/skill level as the rest of the project. So, I am "ditching" these dovetail pieces and transitioning to rabbet joints (not as strong, not as "flashy", but adequate) with oak dowels for added strength and appearance. I actually bought enough wood to cover this design change when I had to replace the pins on dovetail number two that I cut matching the tails (oops!).
I made a quick and expedient marking gauge.
![]()
The only thing to buy is a thumb screw and dowel. Cheap.
![]()
Works pretty well on soft yellow pine.
![]()
Also made a couple of bench hooks out of some scrap white pine I had laying around. Really soft wood, but works for what I am doing. Really makes cutting the joints (all straight cuts now) so much easier - and more accurate!
![]()
Not extremely precise, but accurate enough and square enough for what I am doing on this project. It is pretty soft wood, but I don't have any wood that is actually that hard except for a couple of tiny sticks of red oak. Otherwise I have always worked with construction lumber which is fairly soft (except for some old seasoned wood from old chicken barns and old farm houses).
![]()
OK, here is the first rabbet cut - all made with just the back saw. Not too shabby. I'm getting better at cutting my straight cuts accurately. I'm thankful for that.
![]()
Straight lines, straight cuts. The marking gauge helps a lot.
![]()
This is the first rabbet joint held together to see how close my saw cuts come to fitting. Acceptable. I like the way it looks too.
![]()
Two pieces cut exactly the same. I like it!
![]()
Thank you RustyHacksaw!Transition from Dovetails to Rabbet Joints
If thy dovetail offend thee, cut it off!
![]()
I decided to not use these dovetails that I have been practicing on. I read on two different articles that you should practice on scrap wood and not on your project (which is what I have been doing). Plus, I want the joints to reflect a similar quality/skill level as the rest of the project. So, I am "ditching" these dovetail pieces and transitioning to rabbet joints (not as strong, not as "flashy", but adequate) with oak dowels for added strength and appearance. I actually bought enough wood to cover this design change when I had to replace the pins on dovetail number two that I cut matching the tails (oops!).
I made a quick and expedient marking gauge.
![]()
The only thing to buy is a thumb screw and dowel. Cheap.
![]()
Works pretty well on soft yellow pine.
![]()
Also made a couple of bench hooks out of some scrap white pine I had laying around. Really soft wood, but works for what I am doing. Really makes cutting the joints (all straight cuts now) so much easier - and more accurate!
![]()
Not extremely precise, but accurate enough and square enough for what I am doing on this project. It is pretty soft wood, but I don't have any wood that is actually that hard except for a couple of tiny sticks of red oak. Otherwise I have always worked with construction lumber which is fairly soft (except for some old seasoned wood from old chicken barns and old farm houses).
![]()
OK, here is the first rabbet cut - all made with just the back saw. Not too shabby. I'm getting better at cutting my straight cuts accurately. I'm thankful for that.
![]()
Straight lines, straight cuts. The marking gauge helps a lot.
![]()
This is the first rabbet joint held together to see how close my saw cuts come to fitting. Acceptable. I like the way it looks too.
![]()
Two pieces cut exactly the same. I like it!
![]()
Builds coming along nicely, looking forward the final result. Are you planning on using Japanese planes with this bench?Oak Dowels in Screw Holes
From my "bunk bed" screws holding the rails on while the glue dries overnight, to 5/16" oak dowels glued in enlarged holes.
![]()
Here are four more pins for the next rail.
![]()
Gluing up the top rail now using new HF 1/2" pipe clamps. At first I didn't think they were going to work. The back clamp wanted to slide badly. But after I took some Coleman stove fuel to the pipes to remove much of that gummy, waxy finish they worked brilliantly. They are a little bit heavy, but they seem to work fine so far. I have pre-drilled (drill press so they will be perpendicular) some 3/16" pilot holes through the top and sides so that after the glue dries, I can enlarge the holes for dowel pins to match the bracing rails/stretchers.
![]()
This joint closed up nicely. Looks OK.
![]()
More dowels prepped for installation.
![]()
I put the remaining dowels in the first assembly. I skipped a step (finish drilling pilot holes in the top rail and uprights) and that was a mistake. I thought I could drill the 5/16" hole straight the rest of the way (I had gone so far as to drill 3/16" pilot holes in the top part of the joint on my drill press before gluing the pieces together.) Almost all of the 6 remaining dowel holes were crooked. One barely blew out the side of the upright (bleep!) It's not noticeable, but I know it's there, and I know its a mistake that I shouldn't have made. Why do I get in such a hurry? I've been really taking my time sawing and chipping out the dados by hand with my sharp chisel. Then I get careless and do this. Lesson learned? I wonder sometimes.
![]()
Here is the second upright assembly (that goes with the first one to make the first saw bench/saw horse). I glued the stretcher rails up last night and used the bunk bed screws to hold it together while the glue dried. I used a little bit more glue on this one than the first one and was worried about glue getting on the screws and them being difficult to remove, but they came out very easily. These screws seem to have a plastic waxy coating on them that shows no signs of glue being able to stick to it in any way. I bought them at Lowes and they came 50 to a box for about $19. At the time I bought them I didn't know if I was going to leave them in as a fastener or not so I bought enough to cover all the places I would put them. They were worth the money for sure - excellent screws.
![]()
And the shop as I was leaving to let glue dry until I come back. The pieces for the second saw bench/saw horse are in the background.
![]()
My new flush saw. It's a HF buy, but it works for what I need it to. I would not use it on anything "fine" though - it's so sharp and jagged that it wants to cut into the surrounding wood as well as the dowels. But the handle is pretty fancy looking wood! It as the best looking one on the rack and had that speckled look, so I chose this one.
![]()
Here are the screws:
![]()
Cut off oak dowels.
![]()
This is a clearer image of the dark oak dowels in contrast to the lighter yellow pine. Looks good I think.
![]()
The pattern of the grain in the oak dowels is almost checkered or speckled.
![]()
One of the finished rails.
![]()
Hello siavosh,Oak Dowels in Screw Holes
From my "bunk bed" screws holding the rails on while the glue dries overnight, to 5/16" oak dowels glued in enlarged holes.
![]()
Here are four more pins for the next rail.
![]()
Gluing up the top rail now using new HF 1/2" pipe clamps. At first I didn't think they were going to work. The back clamp wanted to slide badly. But after I took some Coleman stove fuel to the pipes to remove much of that gummy, waxy finish they worked brilliantly. They are a little bit heavy, but they seem to work fine so far. I have pre-drilled (drill press so they will be perpendicular) some 3/16" pilot holes through the top and sides so that after the glue dries, I can enlarge the holes for dowel pins to match the bracing rails/stretchers.
![]()
This joint closed up nicely. Looks OK.
![]()
More dowels prepped for installation.
![]()
I put the remaining dowels in the first assembly. I skipped a step (finish drilling pilot holes in the top rail and uprights) and that was a mistake. I thought I could drill the 5/16" hole straight the rest of the way (I had gone so far as to drill 3/16" pilot holes in the top part of the joint on my drill press before gluing the pieces together.) Almost all of the 6 remaining dowel holes were crooked. One barely blew out the side of the upright (bleep!) It's not noticeable, but I know it's there, and I know its a mistake that I shouldn't have made. Why do I get in such a hurry? I've been really taking my time sawing and chipping out the dados by hand with my sharp chisel. Then I get careless and do this. Lesson learned? I wonder sometimes.
![]()
Here is the second upright assembly (that goes with the first one to make the first saw bench/saw horse). I glued the stretcher rails up last night and used the bunk bed screws to hold it together while the glue dried. I used a little bit more glue on this one than the first one and was worried about glue getting on the screws and them being difficult to remove, but they came out very easily. These screws seem to have a plastic waxy coating on them that shows no signs of glue being able to stick to it in any way. I bought them at Lowes and they came 50 to a box for about $19. At the time I bought them I didn't know if I was going to leave them in as a fastener or not so I bought enough to cover all the places I would put them. They were worth the money for sure - excellent screws.
![]()
And the shop as I was leaving to let glue dry until I come back. The pieces for the second saw bench/saw horse are in the background.
![]()
My new flush saw. It's a HF buy, but it works for what I need it to. I would not use it on anything "fine" though - it's so sharp and jagged that it wants to cut into the surrounding wood as well as the dowels. But the handle is pretty fancy looking wood! It as the best looking one on the rack and had that speckled look, so I chose this one.
![]()
Here are the screws:
![]()
Cut off oak dowels.
![]()
This is a clearer image of the dark oak dowels in contrast to the lighter yellow pine. Looks good I think.
![]()
The pattern of the grain in the oak dowels is almost checkered or speckled.
![]()
One of the finished rails.
![]()
Hi Rodney, I've taken a couple classes in Japanese woodworking and such, I'm not expert whatsoever, so take this unsolicited advice for what it's worth. I don't think you missed much on those two items. Vintage non-replaceable blade saws require almost a master to sharpen, from my understanding a descent job sharpening a Japanese saw is a lot harder than Western saws. In Japan, there are specialty saw sharpeners where that's all they do (there's fewer and fewer of them). I was always recommended to not deal with the hassle and buy replaceable blade ryoba, especially when first starting out. Gyokucho is very easy to find and respected brand.Oak Dowels in Screw Holes
From my "bunk bed" screws holding the rails on while the glue dries overnight, to 5/16" oak dowels glued in enlarged holes.
![]()
Here are four more pins for the next rail.
![]()
Gluing up the top rail now using new HF 1/2" pipe clamps. At first I didn't think they were going to work. The back clamp wanted to slide badly. But after I took some Coleman stove fuel to the pipes to remove much of that gummy, waxy finish they worked brilliantly. They are a little bit heavy, but they seem to work fine so far. I have pre-drilled (drill press so they will be perpendicular) some 3/16" pilot holes through the top and sides so that after the glue dries, I can enlarge the holes for dowel pins to match the bracing rails/stretchers.
![]()
This joint closed up nicely. Looks OK.
![]()
More dowels prepped for installation.
![]()
I put the remaining dowels in the first assembly. I skipped a step (finish drilling pilot holes in the top rail and uprights) and that was a mistake. I thought I could drill the 5/16" hole straight the rest of the way (I had gone so far as to drill 3/16" pilot holes in the top part of the joint on my drill press before gluing the pieces together.) Almost all of the 6 remaining dowel holes were crooked. One barely blew out the side of the upright (bleep!) It's not noticeable, but I know it's there, and I know its a mistake that I shouldn't have made. Why do I get in such a hurry? I've been really taking my time sawing and chipping out the dados by hand with my sharp chisel. Then I get careless and do this. Lesson learned? I wonder sometimes.
![]()
Here is the second upright assembly (that goes with the first one to make the first saw bench/saw horse). I glued the stretcher rails up last night and used the bunk bed screws to hold it together while the glue dried. I used a little bit more glue on this one than the first one and was worried about glue getting on the screws and them being difficult to remove, but they came out very easily. These screws seem to have a plastic waxy coating on them that shows no signs of glue being able to stick to it in any way. I bought them at Lowes and they came 50 to a box for about $19. At the time I bought them I didn't know if I was going to leave them in as a fastener or not so I bought enough to cover all the places I would put them. They were worth the money for sure - excellent screws.
![]()
And the shop as I was leaving to let glue dry until I come back. The pieces for the second saw bench/saw horse are in the background.
![]()
My new flush saw. It's a HF buy, but it works for what I need it to. I would not use it on anything "fine" though - it's so sharp and jagged that it wants to cut into the surrounding wood as well as the dowels. But the handle is pretty fancy looking wood! It as the best looking one on the rack and had that speckled look, so I chose this one.
![]()
Here are the screws:
![]()
Cut off oak dowels.
![]()
This is a clearer image of the dark oak dowels in contrast to the lighter yellow pine. Looks good I think.
![]()
The pattern of the grain in the oak dowels is almost checkered or speckled.
![]()
One of the finished rails.
![]()
Starting to look like something to work on, oh, wait its a great workbench. Looks good my friend..Gluing Up The Feet
Here is a shot of the upright posts in their "sandwich" mortises.
![]()
Left side: C-clamps do the job.
![]()
Right side: Pittsburgh bar clamps and one C-clamp.
![]()
Almost complete.
![]()
Front and back upright assemblies are skewed by about 3/16".
![]()
It's beautiful wood though!
![]()
And the top rails are dead even in height.
![]()
Thanks benchbuilder. I am really satisfied with how it is coming out. It's 1/2 of a fancy set of "legs" for my work slab that I'll be bringing down before long. These 2 X 12s have really been nice to work on too though. One down, one to go. Got a little more done on the feet tonight - put some oak nails (dowels) in for good measure (you can't see the back side in this photo, but the dowels stop about 3/16" from the surface so they only show on the front side, but they go almost full length through everything):Gluing Up The Feet
Here is a shot of the upright posts in their "sandwich" mortises.
![]()
Left side: C-clamps do the job.
![]()
Right side: Pittsburgh bar clamps and one C-clamp.
![]()
Almost complete.
![]()
Front and back upright assemblies are skewed by about 3/16".
![]()
It's beautiful wood though!
![]()
And the top rails are dead even in height.
![]()