LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner
  • Please post in our Community Feedback thread for help with the new forum software! If you are having trouble logging in, please Contact Us for assistance.
1 - 10 of 10 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
64 Posts
All:

Relative newbie here…

Recently, I've seen some pictures of some projects that looked like walnut or even cocobolo, but come to find out, was pine. My window sashes and jambs in my house are pine (aluminum clad on the outside) but my casing is oak. I managed to figure out a formula where I first applied diluted shellac and applied some stain to the pine in order to get it to match the golden oak finish I was using on the casing. The color is near identical.

Typically, oak typically has a honeyed color. Maple is very light. Walnut is dark. Cherry has some reddish hues (at least what I've seen here… might have been before the wood has 'aged' a significant period of time).

So, here is the crux of my question: If you were to pick one wood species, knowing you could stain it to "simulate" other wood species (at least at first glance), what species would you use?

FYI, I am looking to save some money on a large project. I like the look of Cherry, but can't really afford that at this time for this project. Like I said before, I've done some good color matching with pine, but, maybe I'd like something harder/heavier. Dunno, I could be talked into about anything. Give me your opinions if you have time to spare them.

Thanks

Rick
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,904 Posts
As a remodeling contractor this is something that I run into all the time.

Poplar is one of the most used. If you go with a darker tone, solid body stain like Sherwin Willams BAC wiping stain or MLCampbell's wiping stain, you will get a look that simulates other species.

Alder is another one that is good and poplar or alder is often used to simulate cherry and is often referred to as "poor man's cherry." Alder tends to come as knotty or clear, knotty alder is less expensive as you can guess than clear.

Poplar comes in white wood to hues of green, with streaks of purple and even black. If you stay away from the dark streaks, a heavy body stain as mentioned before will cover nicely. The heavy body stains are high in pigment and solids content and they cover the colors well.

Poplar is often used as a paint grade trim. It mills and cuts wonderfully, very similar to cherry. It is more stable than pine and is relatively inexpensive. Trim companies offer a wide variety of profiles in poplar and the stock can be easily found in boards as 4/4", 6/4", or 8/4" by 14" wide and 12' long.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,904 Posts
This is the interior of a big house that I built with my brother. The interior is all trimmed out in poplar and stained with a cherry-like color. This includes the base trim, the light trough and sconces that cap the rock columns, the door and window casing, the beam wraps on the ceiling, all the wood between the big windows.

SV101510

img418
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,820 Posts
Not to digress from the OP's question…which has been quite adequately answered….but, Todd, you do beautiful work!
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
3,675 Posts
Nuther Poplar vote! A friend of mine built his home, he used Poplar for all of his woodwork throughout the house and he and his wife were very satisfied with it for about 14 years. I only use real hardwoods for my woodworking, I choose the wood depending on color desired, never use stain. She started quilting so I built her a Mahogany quilt rack. She loved the looks of it but didn't know what it was until they asked me, when I told them they thought I was joking. They both told me that thier bedroom had Mahogany moldings all through the room and it was a lot darker red color than my rack. I showed them pictures online of Mahogany compared to that stain they used. He is still mad at me, he had to replace all the molding in thier master suite to real mahogany to match the quilt rack.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,904 Posts
This house was designed in the prairie style. It is a beautiful house full of features that the clients, my brother, and I personally designed.

Cooper House

The Cooper House At Night.
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top