Thanks for the vote of confidence, Scott. Rick, I find it much easier to apply poly as a wipe on product. This is simply straight poly diluted 50:50 with mineral spirits. There is no need to break out any measuring devices since the acutal concentration is not critical. I just eyeball it and generally make up a gallon at a time.
With wipe on products you will have to apply 4 to 6 coats to get the build that you want but it dries quickly and you can often apply multiple coats in a single day (this is temperature dependent, of course). Wipe on varnishes help eliminate the sags/runs and brush strokes that come with application of concentrated products and, because they dry so quickly, they have less time for the finish to pick up dust particles.
So to answer your question, if I were doing this finish, I would simply apply a wipe on varnish until I get the build that I like.
One note I would add is that since this is a stained piece, and I am assuming that you used an oil base stain, I would also apply a seal coat of 2# shellac before applying the poly. You could get by without this step but it just prevents the stain from being lifted off by the poly.
A forum community dedicated to professional woodworkers and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about shop safety, wood, carpentry, lumber, finishing, tools, machinery, woodworking related topics, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!