LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner
  • Please post in our Community Feedback thread for help with the new forum software! If you are having trouble logging in, please Contact Us for assistance.
1 - 6 of 6 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
The search for the perfect Bench

Its time to replace my old workbench. I've been using a bench I built years ago from a Norm Abrams design. I had just purchased my old 1906 Home after watching too many series of This Old House and thought, " I could do that". I watched Norm work on a number of old houses and knew at the time, the only way I could afford a large home that was exactly like I wanted would be to buy an old house in need of work and then renovate it to exactly what I would like to see. This was so long ago, that Bob Villa was still the host! During those shows, I was always impressed with Norm Abrams and his abilities to renovate and work in wood. Shortly thereafter, Norm started his own series "New Yankee Workshop". I quickly purchased the New Yankee Workshop Plan Book and started to build a workbench based on the plans in that book. It worked out well when I needed it. I've had it for about 16 years now. Its served me well, but it has its short comings and I just need a new Workbench.

Here is a picture of the old bench


As you can see, it is still in pretty good shape, and well used. It has an interesting vise that I essentially built from Hard Rock Maple and a screw vise that I believe I purchased from the internet a long time ago..



There are a number of things that I don't like about it, besides the limited functionality of the vise. The tool tray is always full of tools and clutter. I don't know about you guys, but mine always looks like the photo below. So, I am considering not putting in a tool tray, as I will just clutter it up!



As you can see from the picture below, I need to finsih some of the doors from my old house and I cant get them on the bench and use the vise to secure them. So, I obviously need a longer bench, as I have 13 doors to finish in my house! So, the new bench will need to be longer…

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
624 Posts
The search for the perfect Bench

Its time to replace my old workbench. I've been using a bench I built years ago from a Norm Abrams design. I had just purchased my old 1906 Home after watching too many series of This Old House and thought, " I could do that". I watched Norm work on a number of old houses and knew at the time, the only way I could afford a large home that was exactly like I wanted would be to buy an old house in need of work and then renovate it to exactly what I would like to see. This was so long ago, that Bob Villa was still the host! During those shows, I was always impressed with Norm Abrams and his abilities to renovate and work in wood. Shortly thereafter, Norm started his own series "New Yankee Workshop". I quickly purchased the New Yankee Workshop Plan Book and started to build a workbench based on the plans in that book. It worked out well when I needed it. I've had it for about 16 years now. Its served me well, but it has its short comings and I just need a new Workbench.

Here is a picture of the old bench


As you can see, it is still in pretty good shape, and well used. It has an interesting vise that I essentially built from Hard Rock Maple and a screw vise that I believe I purchased from the internet a long time ago..



There are a number of things that I don't like about it, besides the limited functionality of the vise. The tool tray is always full of tools and clutter. I don't know about you guys, but mine always looks like the photo below. So, I am considering not putting in a tool tray, as I will just clutter it up!



As you can see from the picture below, I need to finsih some of the doors from my old house and I cant get them on the bench and use the vise to secure them. So, I obviously need a longer bench, as I have 13 doors to finish in my house! So, the new bench will need to be longer…

Mate you dont need to ditch the tool tray, you need to get a trash can! Build some under bench storage on your next workbench and put all your small tools in there. I like the small end vice, it looks handy for holding stock for planning and could just be the solution im looking for. How does it perform for you? Look forward to the project.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
948 Posts
The search for the perfect Bench

Its time to replace my old workbench. I've been using a bench I built years ago from a Norm Abrams design. I had just purchased my old 1906 Home after watching too many series of This Old House and thought, " I could do that". I watched Norm work on a number of old houses and knew at the time, the only way I could afford a large home that was exactly like I wanted would be to buy an old house in need of work and then renovate it to exactly what I would like to see. This was so long ago, that Bob Villa was still the host! During those shows, I was always impressed with Norm Abrams and his abilities to renovate and work in wood. Shortly thereafter, Norm started his own series "New Yankee Workshop". I quickly purchased the New Yankee Workshop Plan Book and started to build a workbench based on the plans in that book. It worked out well when I needed it. I've had it for about 16 years now. Its served me well, but it has its short comings and I just need a new Workbench.

Here is a picture of the old bench


As you can see, it is still in pretty good shape, and well used. It has an interesting vise that I essentially built from Hard Rock Maple and a screw vise that I believe I purchased from the internet a long time ago..



There are a number of things that I don't like about it, besides the limited functionality of the vise. The tool tray is always full of tools and clutter. I don't know about you guys, but mine always looks like the photo below. So, I am considering not putting in a tool tray, as I will just clutter it up!



As you can see from the picture below, I need to finsih some of the doors from my old house and I cant get them on the bench and use the vise to secure them. So, I obviously need a longer bench, as I have 13 doors to finish in my house! So, the new bench will need to be longer…

If you haven't read it already, I highly suggest Chris Schwarz's book Workbenches: From Design and Theory to Construction and Use. He really talks about the pros and cons of a great many workbench features. Like you, he finds that tool trays tend to attract clutter, though I believe he refers to them as rats nests or something similar. Really, most folks I've talked to who've read it agree that it seems to be the seminal text on workbenches.

That wagon vise you've got on your bench currently is actually pretty good for a lot of things, but I wouldn't want that as my only vise. Perhaps adding a face vise of some type in the mean time will make your bench a bit more functional for you until you have a chance to build you a new bench.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,215 Posts
The search for the perfect Bench

Its time to replace my old workbench. I've been using a bench I built years ago from a Norm Abrams design. I had just purchased my old 1906 Home after watching too many series of This Old House and thought, " I could do that". I watched Norm work on a number of old houses and knew at the time, the only way I could afford a large home that was exactly like I wanted would be to buy an old house in need of work and then renovate it to exactly what I would like to see. This was so long ago, that Bob Villa was still the host! During those shows, I was always impressed with Norm Abrams and his abilities to renovate and work in wood. Shortly thereafter, Norm started his own series "New Yankee Workshop". I quickly purchased the New Yankee Workshop Plan Book and started to build a workbench based on the plans in that book. It worked out well when I needed it. I've had it for about 16 years now. Its served me well, but it has its short comings and I just need a new Workbench.

Here is a picture of the old bench


As you can see, it is still in pretty good shape, and well used. It has an interesting vise that I essentially built from Hard Rock Maple and a screw vise that I believe I purchased from the internet a long time ago..



There are a number of things that I don't like about it, besides the limited functionality of the vise. The tool tray is always full of tools and clutter. I don't know about you guys, but mine always looks like the photo below. So, I am considering not putting in a tool tray, as I will just clutter it up!



As you can see from the picture below, I need to finsih some of the doors from my old house and I cant get them on the bench and use the vise to secure them. So, I obviously need a longer bench, as I have 13 doors to finish in my house! So, the new bench will need to be longer…

Chris also has a really enjoyable blog. He are his entries on benches:

http://blog.woodworking-magazine.com/blog/CategoryView,category,Workbenches.aspx
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
377 Posts
The search for the perfect Bench

Its time to replace my old workbench. I've been using a bench I built years ago from a Norm Abrams design. I had just purchased my old 1906 Home after watching too many series of This Old House and thought, " I could do that". I watched Norm work on a number of old houses and knew at the time, the only way I could afford a large home that was exactly like I wanted would be to buy an old house in need of work and then renovate it to exactly what I would like to see. This was so long ago, that Bob Villa was still the host! During those shows, I was always impressed with Norm Abrams and his abilities to renovate and work in wood. Shortly thereafter, Norm started his own series "New Yankee Workshop". I quickly purchased the New Yankee Workshop Plan Book and started to build a workbench based on the plans in that book. It worked out well when I needed it. I've had it for about 16 years now. Its served me well, but it has its short comings and I just need a new Workbench.

Here is a picture of the old bench


As you can see, it is still in pretty good shape, and well used. It has an interesting vise that I essentially built from Hard Rock Maple and a screw vise that I believe I purchased from the internet a long time ago..



There are a number of things that I don't like about it, besides the limited functionality of the vise. The tool tray is always full of tools and clutter. I don't know about you guys, but mine always looks like the photo below. So, I am considering not putting in a tool tray, as I will just clutter it up!



As you can see from the picture below, I need to finsih some of the doors from my old house and I cant get them on the bench and use the vise to secure them. So, I obviously need a longer bench, as I have 13 doors to finish in my house! So, the new bench will need to be longer…

That style of end vise (wagon vise) has one distasteful trait, it makes the effective length of work 6-8in shorter than the bench you install it on. I really like the design and implementation otherwise.

I chose a quick release vise on my new bench. It allows me to work material that is 8-10in longer than the benchtop. Twin screw vises are also a decent option for stretching the workholding capacity of your bench.

With my current bench I was able to produce 101.5" length with 8' sheet mdf as the main surface. Check my blog for the series, it is still in the build phase but is coming along nicely.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,464 Posts
The search for the perfect Bench

Its time to replace my old workbench. I've been using a bench I built years ago from a Norm Abrams design. I had just purchased my old 1906 Home after watching too many series of This Old House and thought, " I could do that". I watched Norm work on a number of old houses and knew at the time, the only way I could afford a large home that was exactly like I wanted would be to buy an old house in need of work and then renovate it to exactly what I would like to see. This was so long ago, that Bob Villa was still the host! During those shows, I was always impressed with Norm Abrams and his abilities to renovate and work in wood. Shortly thereafter, Norm started his own series "New Yankee Workshop". I quickly purchased the New Yankee Workshop Plan Book and started to build a workbench based on the plans in that book. It worked out well when I needed it. I've had it for about 16 years now. Its served me well, but it has its short comings and I just need a new Workbench.

Here is a picture of the old bench


As you can see, it is still in pretty good shape, and well used. It has an interesting vise that I essentially built from Hard Rock Maple and a screw vise that I believe I purchased from the internet a long time ago..



There are a number of things that I don't like about it, besides the limited functionality of the vise. The tool tray is always full of tools and clutter. I don't know about you guys, but mine always looks like the photo below. So, I am considering not putting in a tool tray, as I will just clutter it up!



As you can see from the picture below, I need to finsih some of the doors from my old house and I cant get them on the bench and use the vise to secure them. So, I obviously need a longer bench, as I have 13 doors to finish in my house! So, the new bench will need to be longer…

I like your old bench. Before you take it to the dump let me know, I may have a good home for it :)

But I can't wait to see what you come up with for the new bench.
 
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top