I can't imagine I am the only woodworking gardener hanging out around here ("You can lead a hortaculture, but…) so has anyone else used jointer and planer shavings as garden mulch? Is there a reason I shouldn't?
I started using it for that very purpose a couple of years ago but my old man told me I was a fool because it would suck all the nutrients from your plants. Yet… I have some pretty big tomatoes already this year?
Depends on the species I think. My next door neighbors saw me getting ready to dispose of volumes of maple lathe shavings, and they mulched their flower beds with it. So far the plants are thriving, but I think if it were walnut their soil's nutrient balance may have gotten screwed up. From what I understand the high acidity (and possibly other factors) of certain woods isn't so helpful.
So I would say mulch all the poplar, maple, basswood, pine, sassafrass, ash, etc… that you want. But after years of mulching oak, walnut, and exotics you might run into issues.
I thought about using my sawdust as mulch one time, but I started to worry if that might attract termites also. In my area, they can be common. Do you think that may be something to consider?
I do it all the time. I just hate having to toss it out and, since we have a heavy clay soil in our yard, it looked like a win-win situation when I started putting the shavings on the landscaped areas. I have been doing this for years now and not only is a good mulch but it also helps amend the soil.
My last 'major' project (blanket chest) provided me with a significant pile of mulch. Strategic planning and a push broom and leaf blower enabled me to disperse it quite readily to the planting areas adjacent to my drive way.
I think it was in "Mother Earth News", or a similar mag that I read that it takes more nitrogen out of the soil to break down the wood than the wood will give back to the soil. IIRC, they were talking about chips rather than sawdust.
We don't use either around plants as our soils are nitrogen poor, to begin with.
Composting it first would probably work but, I wonder if it might slow the process???
Gene
Black walnut is TOXIC to other plants so is some Cedar,
All wood dust shavings will suck the nitrogen from the soil if not composted, because the composting process uses nitrogen to compost, but if you compost first, the best free stuff you can get.
NOW that is wood NOT ply or mdf ect.
Mark said:
"Black walnut is TOXIC to other plants so is some Cedar,
All wood dust shavings will suck the nitrogen from the soil if not composted, because the composting process uses nitrogen to compost, but if you compost first, the best free stuff you can get.
NOW that is wood NOT ply or mdf ect."
Some friends learned the hard way that walnut shavings are toxic to horses, as well.
The last report I read suggested adding 40 lbs per 1000 lbs of sawdust.
They are talking 40 lbs of nitrogen.
The highest number fertilizer around is 46-0-0 which means 46% nitorgen ( by weight).
You would need quite a bit of it. and it's not all that cheap
Personally I just compost mine in an separate pile and use it after about 5 years to add into my usual compost pile for bulk.
For what it's worth Trees are the most efficient store houses of Carbon on the planet.
We should try to plant trees where ever possible in our cities and towns.
I compost mine first. Coffee grounds have a lot of nitrogen. I pick those up from the coffee houses and put both in a plastic composter along with clippings, food waste, etc.
The sister site Garden Tenders has alot of info about composting.
Shouldn't make any difference. My father's composted his woodchips and sawdust for years. All different types of wood and species. It's worked great as a compost.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could
be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
LumberJocks Woodworking Forum
A forum community dedicated to professional woodworkers and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about shop safety, wood, carpentry, lumber, finishing, tools, machinery, woodworking related topics, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!