LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner
  • Please post in our Community Feedback thread for help with the new forum software! If you are having trouble logging in, please Contact Us for assistance.
1 - 20 of 159 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
361 Posts
I love all the work everybody does, I enjoy taking a half hour or so to go through the posts and comment on stuff here and there. It actually became a hobby in itself. One of my favorite things to do is go through the projects and blog posts on the main page.

Please don't take it the wrong way but…..

Is it reall neccessary to post each pen individually? Why not make a post with all your pens in one shot. When you post individually it takes others from the front page, Then the next thing you know you see 10 projects in a row from the same guy all the same pens just different colors. I think it kinda hurts the other posters. Their projects, sometimes far more interesting, get pushed off the front page, and they never get the exposure they deserve. I don't post projects much so I'm not directly affected by it. But I am sure some folks are. I do look at the pens but it would be easier on the poster and the reader if they were consolidated to 1 or 2 posts as opposed to 20.

Like I said this isn't meant to shoot anyone down. I love checking them out. I do look at all your pens too. I just miss the diversity sometimes. It's almost spammy looking when you see the same poster ten projects in a row. I know its not, but it looks that way.

I'm sorry if I offended anyone with this post. But I"ll be the one to:
point out the elephant in the room…...there he is.

Keep on cutting and keep the projects rolling. I love LJ's and the entire community. I still want to see those pens coming as I'm looking at getting a small lathe just for that. ?Just consolidate to less posts. Please

If I'm out of line please tell me I am. But I think the posters will get a much better response from a single or dual post. as opposed to 10-15. More comments as well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,142 Posts
No to pens are a like, you get a nicer picture if posted one at a time, but dont post one rite after another, I post one at a time each day, and I do miss a few days,
Chuck
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,418 Posts
Sometimes i will build 10 birdhouses at once and although they all have different coloured roofs they still look pretty much the same .
If i do 10 of the same style then i consider it as one project and post it as a single project .
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,101 Posts
I saw an American Flag pen that was really cool, those little stars had me wondering how they were done.

that said,...............pen after pen after pen after pen. they all start to look the same.perhaps a seperate "spot for pens". No offence but I prefer a pen the same diameter as a pencil, like the "Bic"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
148 Posts
I too have wondered about this whole pen thing. Is there really that much demand out there for turned pens that so many people are doing this? To me, they would be impractical if for nothing more than their heftiness. I also prefer the comfort and disposability of a Bic or a Sharpie.

Also, just how creative can you be with a three-inch pen blank?

There, I've said it. Go ahead and slap me.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,616 Posts
I have never turned a pen but I can easily understand why folks do and I like looking at them. I would also like to own a couple. If somebody has a few for sale at a good price and wants to PM me I would enjoy owning one for myself and my wife. Heck, I think I would also pick one up for my brother.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,787 Posts
I would never want to do anything that would discourage people from posting a project and I really don't care if they post 1 pen per project or a dozen.

In response to Clarence - - My wife owned and ran a flower shop for several years. I displayed and sold some of my smaller woodworking projects in her store. The only real money maker for me was pens. I could use $8 - $10 of material, 20 minutes of labor and sell them for $25 - $40. They always sold well. You can get your labor down to 20 minutes each if you make them in bulk (at least 10 at a time).

I sold lots of other stuff (clocks, bowls, bottle stoppers, etc.) but I seldom could get enough money for them to make them profitable although I did reasonably well with bottle stoppers.

FYI - My wife has sold her store and I don't plan to make another pen for the rest of my life.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,288 Posts
I remember when a posted project would be on the home page for days. Now there are pages of new projects every day. It used to be considered really bad form to post multiple projects at one time as it bumped others off the home page. These days you are going to be bumped anyway due to the volume of project posts. And the volume of posts will increase evermore as LJs grows. I foresee a time that there are so many projects you may want to filter the new projects to avoid the categories that do not interest you…
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,549 Posts
i agree pretty much with the main point of the original poster. multiple smaller pieces should be grouped together. If i make a set of chairs, they go together. Last Xmas I posted multiples of several different projects together… an ornament, wine bottle balancers, candle holders, and a one-of-a-kind menorah piece - all in one project. whether it's pens or something else, these should be grouped together.

i also agree with the need to filter projects. I dont care to see pens or model trucks, for example, so it'd be nice for these projects to be skipped on my personal page.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,253 Posts
I agree that if you have a bunch of smaller items to post…do them in a batch…don't post singularly…but sometimes you turn one or two…like those…post…then turn a couple later and want to post them.

The easiest solution here is to skip over the pens if you do not like seeing them in single groups….I do this when I am not particularly interested in that project at that time…or if I have nothing to offer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,339 Posts
Greetings all: Here's my take on this subject, since it's been brought up, and I'm glad it was. I think Martin should put a limit on on the number of projects and blogs…. say 1, maybe 2, but 1 would be better. And not allow the same person to post so much. Heck, I saw one guy on here that had 11 projects in a row, and another had 9-10… that's ridiculious. And I agree 100% about all the dang pens on here.. 1 or 2 maybe. I've been here about 8-9 months, and posted ONE project, and a couple of blogs. I have helped some guys build my workbench and router table and posted a pix on the question, but mainly PM'ed them with the info and pixs. It's gonna get out of hand, and noone will get to post anything. It's like jm82435 said.. you don't even have time to look at a project… it's gone before the day's out….. FWIW….
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,567 Posts
Posting projects is what attracted me to lumberjocks. I don't want to see a reduction in posts.

I have never turned a pen, and most likely never will. But I appreciate the craftsmanship involved. I would like to see more about the process. This is what I made, and here's how I did it - that's what lumberjocks means to me.

The same argument could be made for bowls, tool handles,spoons and and many other projects,and my answer will be the same. Keep them coming.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,709 Posts
The limit on the number of projects per time period has been beaten to death. With 17,000+ members, even a limit of one project a day- well you can see where this is going….

I don't remember anyone complaining about the plethora of cutting boards that appeared here about a year ago.

It's going to run in cycles. Why get so up tight?

Lew
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
555 Posts
I'm right there with ya getneds, and I believe my man feels the same way. I do like looking at the pens myself, and comment on the ones I find really unique and cool…but it does get redundant sometimes when someone makes like 5 all basically the same in different woods and posts them one by one. Since a project post allows you 6 pictures, why not take a group shot and then highlight the best ones with single pictures in that same post…

I did that with my first 2 project postings here on LJ's….I didn't want to bombard the project page with 12 in a row, so I posted my various carvings all as one post, and my various toll painting wood projects all as one post.

OR....here's another idea: make a slideshow (on photobucket or any one of the other photo hosting sites) like my BF does. It allows you to put as many pics as you want on it, and that way you don't dominate the projects page.

We all know once a project gets bumped off the first 2 pages or so, it's pretty much done being seen unless someone goes specifically looking at your work. People will post as they see fit, but I think in the end it just comes down to a courtesy thing. : )
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,426 Posts
When I first joined LJs over a year ago, I got so excited I posted 15 projects on the one day… mind you they were all different.. A very wise man PMed me and let me know that this was not cool.. so now I only post occasionally and if it is a group of items … only one post.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
361 Posts
It's not about being uptight, or hateful.. Like I said, I love the stuff and I don't think any less of the pens being made. I actually look at them, at least most of them. I am interested, but it gets to be a pain in the butt seeing one after another. I don't think we need a post limit, or anything like that. It is more of a courtesy, than anything else. I understand the newbie enthusiasm also. Just consolidate post, because things are getting buried before they appreciated.

Don't think I'm being a jerk, or any other negetive thing. I just would like to see everyones work as a whole.

Heres an Idea. If you have many "like" projects and you want to brief us on all of them use the forum, then you have unlimited space. Then post once to the projects and link to the forum in there.

I love all the stuff on LJ's. I am not discouraging posts. I would like everyone to have a fair chance thats all.

As far as cutting boards, spoons and the like, you're right about it being compulsive. I was still under a year so I kept it to myself. I still plan on doing that, it was just a statment everyone thought of….... I typed it.

Keep cutting….......wood that is.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,652 Posts
A "need"? I don't recall there ever being a "need" for anyone to post anything. Maybe Martin could add that after the question about "Is this a finished woodworking project? Yes/No". "Is there a need to post this project? Yes/No".
 
1 - 20 of 159 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top