LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

Best bang for the buck track saw 2021?

4634 Views 44 Replies 29 Participants Last post by  therealSteveN
I have been wanting a track saw for a while now, and thinking of finally taking the plunge(sorry i'm a dad). Looking at "reviews" online, i noticed most review sites have affiliate links etc. I also see most brands have corded and cordless versions now. And it seems the cordless models don't come with tracks in order to keep their "price" down. There seems to be so many pluses and minuses of the various brands and models, some have better dust collection, some have riving knifes, or pre scoring, chip guards, yadda yadda yadda. Its hard to make sense of what features matter for a hobbyist woodworker. I'm sure some features are important for a pro cabinet shop etc, but what is the best bang for the buck for a hobbyist woodworker?
1 - 20 of 45 Posts
Best bang for the buck has to be the low end (Wen for example). You get 75-85% of the performance for 30% of the price of a Festool. But, you can't option your way up to something that works as well, so once you reach the limit, it's a total loss and start again. The low end track saws really work. The track works pretty much the same way, you get pretty much the same set of functions in the saw, the cut quality is nearly the same, and all the basic things you do with the saw can be done with the low end units. What you don't get is things like the riving knife, the accessories for MFT, etc. The low end tracks aren't made as well so they slide around more, the separate sections are sometimes tricky to get assembled so the saw slides smoothly across the joint, the splinter guard doesn't hold up as well and the dust collection isn't as good. Lots of plastic parts that can break.

I have one, and I use it to break down sheet goods. Works like a champ. I usually don't try to get finished sized pieces out of that, but I could on most materials if I wanted to. If you get a cheap one, upgrade the blade.
See less See more
You get 75-85% of the performance for 30% of the price of a Festool.

- brtech
How do you quantify performance like that? Based on what?
I say with ABSOLUTE CONFIDENCE that the new (upgrade from their 6.5" 10amp) WEN 7.25" 12 amp was well worth the $. About $250 including 100" of track and 7" clamps. Ordered from Home Depot. Very happy with it. Did a better job than my jointer on 8'x8"x 8/4 boards and just as well as my buddies Festool.

Love that saw.

Camera accessory Font Gas Output device Cameras & optics

Attachments

See less See more
2
I reckon it depends on how much precision you need. Some saws/track combos can arguably rip glue joints while others have undependably straight tracks and may have less precise manufacturing that affects the quality of cut. It's the same question as whether a higher end circular saw cuts the same as a Black and Decker… and the answer would be it depends on closely you look.

I've had 3 track saws and 3 brands of track. I like the Festool HK because I like not having to plunge on a straight cut. It does plunge but it also locks down which most plungers do not. The dust collection isn't as good as the other Festool saws and it lacks the right side chip out control feature. Resale value on Festools is excellent while most brands will have you taking a serious hit if you decide to upgrade or get out of woodworking.
See less See more
^+1 Loren is correct. The WEN gave me glue joint quality. I even bought a 60 tooth blade but never put it on. The blade that came on the saw did what it was supposed to do. Ripped one edge with the WEN and the other on my table saw so basically, the WEN did the job of the jointer on S4S boards.
ill give a pitch for the dewalt,have the corded model with long and short track for about 6 years now and love it.you'll need to do your homework and decide what gives you the best bang for your buck.
Wen - very interesting, not a name I think of when looking for a quality tool. Maybe they've up'd their game, stuff I've seen in the past was quite underwhelming to say the least
Depends on your intent. If just breaking 4×8's down for the TS, then a top of the line saw is more than you need for the job at hand. If you are going for final dimension accuracy then one of the better saws with a good blade is justified from my point of view.
Thanks for that info Andy. I've been toying with buying a "cheaper" track saw for a while now. I think I'll pull the trigger based on your recommendation. I did look at it on the HD website too, and it looks good to me.
Thanks for that info Andy. I ve been toying with buying a "cheaper" track saw for a while now. I think I ll pull the trigger based on your recommendation. I did look at it on the HD website too, and it looks good to me.

- JRAP
I thought it was broken when I first got it. I tried to hog through all 8/4 at one time and it kept cutting off. Silly me. Then I realized from listening closely to the vids that guys were making those cuts in 2 or 3 passes. Even my friend with the Festool said he can't do one pass. Once I realized that I was a happy camper and happy with my purchase. The edge was just as smooth as a jointer or table saw with the stock blade that came with it. Never took the 60 toothe out of the wrapper. The WEN tracks fit other brands inc. Festool. Get the tracks and clamps. Like I said, less then $250 for everything.

PS The other benefit of the track saw is that you don't have to muscle big boards on the jointer. The boards stay put. The saw moves.

It's basically a light-duty skill saw that plunges.
See less See more
Hmm never considered Wen. Tbh, i had kind of been considering Dewalt or makita corded, but also curious how the Kreg stacks up against those 2. I am also not opposed to paying for Festool if it is really worth it for some reason that i hadn't thought of. I sometimes build cabinets or cabinet like furniture, so would like to cut down 3/4 sheets. But I also normally buy s2s as my local lumberyard carries mostly s2s and s3s. So sometimes i need to make a flat side before running through the TS. Though, the more i could use it in place of the TS the better, for various reasons.
Best bang for the buck has to be the low end (Wen for example). You get 75-85% of the performance for 30% of the price of a Festool. But, you can t option your way up to something that works as well, so once you reach the limit, it s a total loss and start again. The low end track saws really work. The track works pretty much the same way, you get pretty much the same set of functions in the saw, the cut quality is nearly the same, and all the basic things you do with the saw can be done with the low end units. What you don t get is things like the riving knife, the accessories for MFT, etc. The low end tracks aren t made as well so they slide around more, the separate sections are sometimes tricky to get assembled so the saw slides smoothly across the joint, the splinter guard doesn t hold up as well and the dust collection isn t as good. Lots of plastic parts that can break.

I have one, and I use it to break down sheet goods. Works like a champ. I usually don t try to get finished sized pieces out of that, but I could on most materials if I wanted to. If you get a cheap one, upgrade the blade.

- brtech
I'm sure there are a few saws rebranded as other makes made in the same Asian factory. WEN has an anti-kickback mechanism that seems to work well. Tracks are solid and my 8' straight edge says they are straight. They don't slide. I'm sure the Festool is a better made tool but as a weekend warrior, I just can't justify the additional cost. The stock 45 tooth blade works just fine. Same reason I bought the Bosch instead of the Festool Rotex. Cut this chamfer just like the guy on youtube did with his Festool.

See less See more
2
I picked up the Makita cordless a couple years back and have been very pleased with it. I was looking for a quality tool but am still unwilling to dive into Festool. At he time I bought there were the low end like Wen's previous models, the Dewalt or Makita, or Festool. Bosch had not come out with there's in the American market. I looked at the Triton but felt it was over priced for what it is. The current Wen saw is probably on par with the Triton but at less cost. I looked seriously at the Dewalt which seems to be a good saw. What tipped the scales for me was the compatibility of the Makita with available accessories. As most accessories are built for the Festool, they generally work with the Makita as well.

I currently have 2 - 55" tracks and one 39". They have handled everything I have neede so far. It would be nice to have the 118" track but I have gotten by with joining the 2-55" tracks for now. Recently I even added on the 39" track for straight edging some 10' 8/4 oak. I keep the 39" track hanging conveniently in the shop for quick cuts and have now found it to be indispensable.

By the way, I have found the Triton track connector kit to be a bargain over the Makita connectors. The screws in the Triton kit are kind of soft so I replaced them with some from the local hardware store. Even adding the minimal extra cost for the hardware, they are half the price of the Makita. Especially if you get them when rockler has the Triton products on sale.
See less See more
If you measure carefully or use parallel guides there is no need to use a track saw to break down sheets and then further process them on a table saw. A track saw will replace a table saw for cutting sheet goods. It will give you the same straight cut with a smooth finish and with no tear out.
I recently bought a Makita track saw and tracks, and after using it for a few months I am very pleased with it.
I've had a DeWalt with 8' and 4' tracks for around 6 years now and it has been a consistent performer. I can't manhandle sheet goods like I used to and this provides a way to cut down into reasonable portions. Also comes in handy when dealing with finish cuts on large table tops, especially crosscuts.
In a perfect world I think I'd want a small cordless for rough breakdown of sheet goods - possibly even in parking lot - and a high quality (as apparently the new Wen is) with a one-piece track.
I have the older Wen, its fine, but could really use a one-piece track 8ft+.
In a perfect world I think I d want a small cordless for rough breakdown of sheet goods - possibly even in parking lot - and a high quality (as apparently the new Wen is) with a one-piece track.
I have the older Wen, its fine, but could really use a one-piece track 8ft+.

- JohnMcClure
The tracks are 50". They use a connector to expand to 100".
Hmm never considered Wen. Tbh, i had kind of been considering Dewalt or makita corded, but also curious how the Kreg stacks up against those 2. I am also not opposed to paying for Festool if it is really worth it for some reason that i hadn't thought of. I sometimes build cabinets or cabinet like furniture, so would like to cut down 3/4 sheets. But I also normally buy s2s as my local lumberyard carries mostly s2s and s3s. So sometimes i need to make a flat side before running through the TS. Though, the more i could use it in place of the TS the better, for various reasons.

- SMP
I have the full Kreg ACS. It is good, but, IMO, the real strength is in the integration with the table. If you're not considering the table somewhere down the line, I don't know that it offers a lot in terms of differentiation.
1 - 20 of 45 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top