LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

Project Information

A couple of months ago, I was reading Sheila Landry's blog entries (as I do most every day) and became very interested in a box she antiqued using paint and some really wonderful stenciling techniques.

It got me thinking. What would it take to create an item that would look perfectly at home on a shelf in an antique store and fool it's owner into thinking it was at least a hundred years old?

Here's what two month's of mulling this over and a couple of day's worth of work in the shop resulted in - a box that would (hopefully) fool most of the people most of the time.

Here's a few items I've noted when trying to turn an item old:

1) Study similar items that are actually old! You get a lot of subtle clues from this - in this case, the staining in and in front of the finger hole. I wouldn't have thought to do this. Also the wear marks at either end.

2) Less is more. Don't overdo it. I scrapped the first label I made for this because it looked too old - and fake.

3) Say NO to perfection. The folks making these boxes in the 1890's didn't care about perfection, neither should you.

The box itself was a section of dimensional poplar last week. I used the table saw to re-saw it into two pieces and a very simple box-joint jig for the joints.

I used a slew of things to make it appear aged, but the number one item in my arsenal this time was powdered graphite - it instantly made the box look stained and old.

After that I used water-based varnish and put it on pretty thick as I wanted it bit of a blush to develop.

Dimensions of the box are around 10×3x3 "ish".

My wife quickly claimed this one claiming she needed a box for her cosmetics - how appropriate!

Oh yeah! I am seriously looking for some comments on this project - please let me know what gives this away as new, what I over-did or under-did, etc…....

Thanks!

-bob

Gallery

Comments

· Registered
Joined
·
818 Posts
I like the look of this and it certainly looks old and well used .
The label is a great addition and I would like to see more on how you made it .
What gives the age away from what I can see is the interior but another shot of it may change my mind .
 

· Registered
Joined
·
546 Posts
I really like the box! Well done.

The only reason I'd even notice or think to look for details proving it's not really aged is because you asked. In other words, challenge accepted!

A few comments that may or may not be legit, because it's hard to tell from photos:

1. I'd like to see scratches run into the label. It appears that they run under the label.
2. Love the random damage, but the planed edges look planed, rather than worn. I suspect you could use something a bit more primitive to introduce wear, as opposed to a cutting tool.
3. Think about the pattern normal wear from use would leave. You'd hold it somewhere and then slide the lid open. For sure, I'd expect to see a nice wear pattern on the notched end of the lid, including the underside of it where the user would pinch it between his fingers while opening it.
4. Wear would wear off the finish, so it would be great to see worn edges of bare wood.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
423 Posts
Nice box.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,002 Posts
I have a couple of very old boxes and as well as you did, you can still tell that it is a new-ish box.

Just to let you know, most of the boxes of age were all rough cut and their wear is what smoothed them out.

You did a wonderful job and as such you could probably make a bunch of these and sell them. They would make really cool novelty boxes. Get a branding iron and brand your name and date on the bottom and back of the lid. And don't forget the labels, the old label look is great - especially old chemicals and the like (that is why you mark them as new). The original boxes that contained these kinds of things were seriously poisonous but they didn't know that at the time. This way, you can assure people that the box is actually safe.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
232 Posts
Todd, Thanks for the notice of the scratches!

I just noticed that they do indeed go UNDER the label instead of run into it - damn! Yes, I affixed the label after distressing it and should have caught that one.

And, BTW, this is a copy of an actual label that hasn't been doctored to read "Poison" - it was actually sold in bottles with this very label on them. Wild, eh?

-bob
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Hopefully you are not going to intentionally try to fool anyone and will put your mark or label on the bottom.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,002 Posts
I could tell that it was a copy of an actual label. You can date the original labels to the skull and crossbones - the companies changed them from time to time. As a kid, I grew up helping a neighbor who sold antiques.

What I was saying, the original wood boxes DID have these chemicals and some were seriously poisonous and were absorbed into the wood, making them every bit as poisonous.

Replicating antiques to be viewed as an antique is not good, making a copy of antiques but acknowledging that it is a really good facsimile is a whole different matter.

I once had a still life painting that was identified a fraud of a master. The person that painted it lived in the early 1900's. She did a great job but she didn't add a key element to the painting - that a good appraiser saw immediately. If was for this reason that the painting was not burned by the museum that bought it. She did a really good job, right down the making the paints from scratch, she just couldn't paint the bugs that are in still life paintings with fruit. When I got it , I sold it as the fake it was and got a good amount of money for it as such. The auction gallery where I sold it even advertised as a seriously good fake - which is appropriate.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
232 Posts
PLEASE let it be known that this was not made to fool anyone - I have signed and dated it on the bottom! :)

Cheers,

-bob
 

· Registered
Joined
·
387 Posts
Bob,
I like the effects, and find it interesting to explore ways of artificially aging an item. It's another challenge that I believe is fully within the prerogative of a box maker. I like both the box and the effect.

It is comforting to know that you were not anticipating forming a world wide antique counterfeiting ring. I see no problem at all with exploring these for your own use, or for full disclosure sale. I expect that these are all fully acceptable restoration techniques, with no misrepresentation intended at all.
Roger
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Glad to hear it, Knot curser. I collect antiques. That being said your box reminds me of antique box that has been refinished, to make it look nicer. In reality this type of box was just a crate-type packing box, I don't think it would have such smooth finish. maybe you need to throw some dirt and grime on there ;-)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
546 Posts
I know rubbing dirt on the wood is an actual technique. Never tried it.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
7,502 Posts
Being young, as I am,...... uhh-humm. uh, I …...... uh…. what were we talking about? .................OH, yea, it looks gr8 to me.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,583 Posts
Yes, the scratch goes under the label. Also, why burn the edges of the label? Have you ever seen a burned edge of a label? It looks out of place. Your wear marks on the ends looks like you took a sander to them. They are faceted. Try going over that with a flap sander or sanding ball to ease the facets. Think of the lines at the amusement parks. Specifically the wooden posts. Thousands of folks per day run their hands across them. Wear like this gets rounded over, not faceted.

As a box, I really like it. Clever with the graphite. Decent job on the label too. And the finger joings are perfect for that era.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
264 Posts
That is awesome! Great job. Any ideal where a fellar could find a label like yours? Love it. Thanks for sharing
 

· Registered
Joined
·
462 Posts
Try running it through a front-loading washing machine, with bleach, and then tumble dry. That oughta do it. :)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,714 Posts
Very nice results!

When I was a lot younger, and working in a radio/TV repair shop, the owner of the shop was a woodworker and many times the profession would cross with his hobby and he was asked to make and antique looking piece of electronics to match the customers requests. He turned out some really old brand new stereos, radios, and speaker systems.
 

· In Loving Memory
Joined
·
8,391 Posts
It looks old to me.
 
Top