LumberJocks

Reply by ColonelTravis

  • Advertise with us

Posted on Looking at LN dovetails saws

View ColonelTravis's profile

ColonelTravis

1976 posts in 2461 days


#1 posted 10-03-2018 01:39 AM

AG – since you asked about a Japanese saw for dovetails, after many recommendations for the Gyokucho 372, I bought one and it’s all I use now for those.

I used to saw with the non-tapered L-N dovetail saw and still have it. After trying the Japanese saw, I found it suited me better as far as the mechanical action of sawing goes. I have one more Japanese saw for crosscuts, otherwise I have no other Japanese tools.

This is why I prefer the 372 for dovetails:

1.) More narrow kerf
2.) Greater TPI. I believe it’s 19 vs. 15 for the L-N.
3.) Cutting on the pull stroke helps me, initially, to follow a straight line right on the line. It’s a subtle difference and maybe it’s psychological, I don’t know. All I know is that I can do it better. Actually, this becomes more of an issue with crosscutting wider boards vs. dovetails. I mean following a line on the top, not one going down the side.

Yes, you will have to replace blades instead of resharpening them. But you will have to go through 5 blades to finally top the cost of the L-N saw (which is close to $140 when you throw in shipping), which will definitely last more than one user’s lifetime. But your own lifetime? I don’t know how old you are now, but if you started as a teenager and cut dovetails regularly for 75 years with a Japanese saw – yeah, you would be spending more than the L-N saw. And you won’t have a family heirloom when you’re dead. I’m not gonna run into that problem because I don’t cut dovetails every day or every week or even every month and I don’t have kids. After three years I’m still on my first blade, I don’t see any signs of it being dull.

Anyway, I’ve never heard anyone say the L-N saw was bad. I’m not saying that, either. All I’m saying is that I found one that was better for me. A Japanese saw might not be the best thing for you.

Are you around any L-N event when they tour the country? They bring everything and you can try everything, I highly recommend going to one if you’re gonna spend that kind of money on their tools and can’t get to Maine. I’ve found out after trying stuff that I liked certain tools I never thought I’d like and disliked others I thought I would like. Either way, I’ve ended up poorer after it was over. I love L-N.

Ooops – just remembered you’re in Alaska. Idiot <—- me. I doubt any L-N event comes closer to you than Seattle.

Good luck!


DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com