Reply by clin

  • Advertise with us

Posted on Calculating the volume of Burial Urns

View clin's profile


1066 posts in 1501 days

#1 posted 08-17-2018 03:13 AM

Not sure you said that right. I think that the cube of the factor only applies if you scale all 3 dimensions by the same factor. If you scale up a single dimension, you can simply multiply the volume by the scale factor to get the new volume. If you have a cylinder that is 3” tall and 3 inches in diameter, it has a volume of 21.2 cubic inches. If you double the height, it is the same as adding a second 3” tall 3” diameter cylinder on top so it simply doubles the volume to 42.4 because you changed only one dimension. If you triple the height only, the new volume is 3 times the original, not 27 times. If you double the diameter (but not the height), that is really the same as doubling 2 dimensions so the area of a cross section will increase by 4 times and volume of the scaled up cylinder is 84.8 which is the same as multiplying the original volume (21.2) by the square of the scale factor (4).

- Lazyman

Lazyman has it right. Though I had to re-read it a few times to understand it.

I’ll restate in my own way. Assuming you have a known volume for some size of urn you already have. Call it Vold.

The new volume is proportional to the change in height. Vnew is given by.

Vnew = Vold x Kh

Kh = Height new / Height old

If you are changing the diameter (width), the volume changes by the square of the change in diameter. As Lazyman pointed out, you are effectively changing width and depth (2 dimensions). If you only changed one of these dimensions, it would become elliptical and not be circular.

Vnew = Vold x Kd^2 = Vold x Kd x Kd (squaring Kd)

Kd = Diameter new / Diameter old

If you are changing both, it make no difference what order you apply these in. You can just say:

Vnew = Vold x Kh x Kd^2

If both the height and width change by the same proportion ( K = Kh = Kd) then you have:

Vnew = Vol x K^3 = Vold x K x K x K (K is cubed).

Note: These of course are based on the interior dimension, not the exterior.

-- Clin

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics