Woodworking in America 2008 #4: Day 3, or like the song says, Is It Over Already?

  • Advertise with us
Blog entry by Texasgaloot posted 11-17-2008 06:17 AM 14140 reads 0 times favorited 4 comments Add to Favorites Watch
« Part 3: Woodworkers are Strange People. Part 4 of Woodworking in America 2008 series Part 5: WIA Wrap-up »

This is just like Christmas as a kid. Every day since early July you mark the calendar with hopeful anticipation (I want an Official Range Model Red Ryder BB gun with a compass in the stock and a thing that tells time!) and then you look around and realize you’re sitting in a sea of wrapping paper and you wish this could go on forever.

My WIA day started with a hands-on clinic offered by Deneb Puchalski of Lie-Nielsen on, wait for it… wait for it… hand planing. Yes. Ooooo… Ahhhhh…

My bench-mate for the morning whipped out a crispy LN No.-7 and then a LN No.-4. One of the other guys brought a couple of shiny wooden planes he made himself (now, THERE’S a galoot!) and someone else had three of every plane Veritas ever made. I reached into my satchel and pulled out my old Stanley No.-4C (with a Hock blade) made in the early 1900’s, my No.-5 made in the ‘50’s, and my No.-8 made in the days of Moses. (Picture the Mommy on Oprah saying she wanted to take her kids to the park but was too fat to fit into the fence gate, lower lip quivering, the audience all “Awwing” their sympathy, and then cue schmaltzy organ music,) I had… plane envy. All this shiny ductile iron with racing stripes and hood scoops and chrome pipes…

I tried my bench-mate’s No.-4. It made thin, wispy, hang-time shavings. Deneb talked about plane setup. Nothing here I hadn’t heard before and read several times before, but all solid. Good tip in this one, though: Deneb keeps a 3×4x1/2” block of wood on his bench, set on edge against a stop, and takes a shaving off with the left side of his blade and then does the same with the right. If the shavings are equal, he then knows that his blade is set square to the plane sole. Good idea.

We had a discussion about plane techniques, how to straighten a cupped board, and then straighten one with twist (plane down the high spots to meet the low spots) and then smooth. Here’s another important tip: when starting with rough cut stock, don’t start with your No.-5’s blade set rank but set at a normal height. If you only get a few little sawdust scrapings at first, it isn’t because your blade is set wrong, it’s because you’re planing only the high spots, which is what you’re supposed to do.

I used my humble No.-5 to flatten my board of evil green poplar (it’s really last year’s Halloween-candy bubble gum that Dad wouldn’t even steal!) My 5 is such a cool workhorse. Nothing flashy about it, but kind of like my pickup, when I hook the horse trailer up to it, it pulls. The board started out with a crown, and in three minutes there was a pile of shavings at my feet and a rough but flat board in front of me. On to the jointer.

Now, I have the same reaction all the time. Folks look at that No.-8, look at me, look back at the plane, look at me… until I finally say, “Look. A plane in motion wants to stay in motion. A bigger plane likes to stay in motion more than a smaller plane.” And then they say something like, “Yeah, well, it’s getting that plane in motion that’s the issue.” It seems to be working for me, because in another three minutes I had a layer of even thinner shavings laying at my feet and a much smoother board in front of me. So then I picked up my smoother. A few STROKES and I had thin, wispy, hang-time shavings and a very smooth board, just as Ron Hock himself walks by and looks at my work (I’m sure he was impressed with my choice of stock.) I picked up one of my translucent shavings and showed it to him, told him that I had a Hock blade, and thanked him for such a fantastic product. I’ve discovered this weekend that tool makers are people too, because Ron’s face noticeably relaxed when he realized I was appreciative of the product of his labors. Folks, let our New Old Tools manufacturers know you appreciate them when you do. Too soon, I was done and off to my last session.

This one was with The Schwartz on preventing tear-out. Now I’ve never had tear-out, and I realize you never have either, but I’ve heard of it happening from time to time, so it was worth hearing what Chris had to say. I took four pages of notes… I can’t even begin to enumerate it all here, so I’ll have to digest it over a little time. The highlight came when Chris related to teaching his very young daughter to read a board (I don’t know if she can read a book, yet!) He used the analogy of one of Mommy’s cats. The cats have fur, and if you pet the fur one way the cat purrs. If you pet the fur the opposite way, the cat bites. He then went over to the dry-erase board where he had drawn his guinea plank, and then added a cat’s tail and a face like Disney’s Cheshire Cat. Now, that’s funny, I don’t care who you are.

We had a lively and interesting discussion on means of preventing tear-out, including and in no particular order, skew angle, blade angle, chip-breaker placement, iron sharpness, gnarly-ness of the individual plank (“Those wood fibers have lived all their lives with their neighbors, and they don’t want to move.”) grain orientation, etc. I promise, I’ll blog on the details after I’ve had some rest.

So, I’ve put my ghetto-shop-apron up for a couple of days. As I write this, my wife and I are hurtling down route 40 between Nashville and Memphis (I think, I haven’t really been paying attention – we could be between Tucson and Phoenix.) And as of tomorrow, I’m going to start marking the calendar for next year.

-- There's no tool like an old tool...

4 comments so far

View ShannonRogers's profile


540 posts in 5002 days

#1 posted 11-17-2008 03:29 PM

Hey kid careful with that #8, you’ll shoot your eye out! HO HO HO! Safe travels to you both and see you next year.

-- The Hand Tool School is Open for Business! Check out my blog and podcast "The Renaissance Woodworker" at

View Thos. Angle's profile

Thos. Angle

4444 posts in 5177 days

#2 posted 11-17-2008 03:48 PM

I wish they had made a #10. I especially appreciate all the time you took to write up the events at this gathering. There is no other way I could have attended. However, through your efforts, I was able to get a feel for it. Thanks again. By the way, my set of planes mirrors your own except my #7 is an old Craftsman(Sargent). I don’t even have Hock irons in all of them yet. And, yeah, they make very whispy shavings.

-- Thos. Angle, Jordan Valley, Oregon

View Lee A. Jesberger's profile

Lee A. Jesberger

6875 posts in 5194 days

#3 posted 11-17-2008 03:50 PM

Hey Tex;

You did a great job with keeping us posted on the event.

It sure sounds like you had a great time, and got to teach those guy’s a thing or two. lol

Those events do seem to go way too quick, don’t they.

Again, great job with this, and I do believe if you are not a writer, you may have missed your calling.


-- by Lee A. Jesberger

View Ampeater's profile


442 posts in 4962 days

#4 posted 11-18-2008 01:25 AM

I really enjoyed all 4 sections of your blog. I was also at the conference, but I signed up too late to get in on any of the ‘hands on’ sessions. I did attend the max of 10 sessions and enjoyed all of them. It appears that we were in some of the same sessions.

I agree that it was totally awesome meeting and talking to all of those great woodworkers and manufacturers.

-- "A goal without a plan is a wish."

Have your say...

You must be signed in to post the comments.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics