In the next few weeks I’ll be building a small workbench to use at work. I’m currently using a fold-away table saw stand (not the table saw itself) with a sort of cradle to hold up double basses and cellos to perform certain repairs because it is lower than the high work table I typically use.
I’ll be building a somewhat traditional style bench about 33 inches high. I want to put a vise on the face and one on the end to use with dog holes. The thing is, as I currently use my space, putting the end vise on the left would be most convenient, so I’d put the face vise on the right end of the bench. This feels correct to me BUT most of the traditional benches I see pictures of have vises on the opposite sides/ends from what I’m thinking.
Is there a real reason behind why other benches are opposite of what I feel I need?
-- Ni faru ion el ligno!
12 comments so far
Dave Polaschek
home | projects | blog
10282 posts in 2040 days
#1 posted 05-07-2019 02:43 PM
End vise on the right is because people plane right handed so they’re pushing against the dogs on the left. And then the end vise on the right means the face vise goes on the left because otherwise they would interfere with each other.
-- Dave - Santa Fe
Dave Rutan
home | projects | blog
2022 posts in 3646 days
#2 posted 05-07-2019 06:01 PM
Thank you! That makes perfect sense. And since I plan on using this to plane fingerboards among other things I’ll have to configure the vises in the ‘traditional’ manner.
-- Ni faru ion el ligno!
FirehouseWoodworking
home | projects | blog
792 posts in 4731 days
#3 posted 05-07-2019 07:56 PM
While Dave is correct, it has traditionally been explained that way as THE way to plane wood. BUT . . . it doesn’t have to be so!
What difference does it make if one planes TOWARDS the bench dog or TOWARDS the vise? Think about it!
The board is held in place by dogs on either end, one typically of wood and the other “pull up dog” typically of steel. But so long as BOTH are properly set BELOW the level of the board to be planes, one does no damage to either bench dog nor to the plane being used!
As far as the board itself, it needs to be snug in the clamped configuration, regardless of the direction of the planing strokes.
Just because one has “always done it this way” does not mean one has to!
And YES . . . It would seem the this is a “Dave thread!” . . . This is my brother Dave and my other brother Dave . . . Me? . . . Why, I’m Dave! . . . Who else would I be? . . .
Cheers!
-- Dave; Lansing, Kansas
Dave Rutan
home | projects | blog
2022 posts in 3646 days
#4 posted 05-07-2019 08:39 PM
Well, the good news is that it sounds like I can go with my original plan.
The bad news I feel like I’m watchuing a tennis match. ;-)
-- Ni faru ion el ligno!
htl
home | projects | blog
5624 posts in 2617 days
#5 posted 05-07-2019 09:31 PM
We’re going to have to start numbering the Dave’s around here if this keeps up. lol
-- An Index Of My Model making Blogs https://www.lumberjocks.com/htl/blog/130264
Jeff Mazur
home | projects | blog
119 posts in 2762 days
#6 posted 05-07-2019 10:33 PM
For me, operating an end vise with my stronger hand is easier and more natural, so I’d recommend you put it on your ”-handed” side. Also, perhaps more compelling: if you put your end vise on the end where your strong hand is, you can brace the bench so that it’s virtually immovable by putting the other end (the end you plane toward) against a wall! You can’t do that if the vise is at the end you plane toward. Hope this is helpful.
-- Woodworking is a beautiful, physical, cerebral, and noble art.
Dave Polaschek
home | projects | blog
10282 posts in 2040 days
#7 posted 05-08-2019 12:48 AM
The traditional way makes sense for bracing against the wall, but I switch off and plane left handed or right handed, and planing towards the vise isn’t a problem using a vise and bench dogs. It does get a mite complicated if you’re using a planing stop and a holdfast, but that doesn’t sound like your setup.
I find that more of my planing nowadays is done on my low bench with a stop and a holdfast, and with me sitting on the bench, planing away from myself (often with a thigh over the wood). But sometimes I put a piece in the face vise on my high bench and plane it there. I think you can set your bench up however you like. There’s a reason for the tradition, but there’s more than one tradition, too.
Good luck whichever way you decide to go, Dave.
-- Dave - Santa Fe
Sylvain
home | projects | blog
1675 posts in 3957 days
#8 posted 05-08-2019 10:07 AM
Some don’t use an end vise, see here
A 33” height might be traditional (from a time were people were smaller an had to plane a lot of rough saw wood with a thick wooden plane) but in my view is low for delicate work.
Now, if you are repairing voluminous objects, you have specific needs.
-- Sylvain, Brussels, Belgium, Europe - The more I learn, the more there is to learn (and that is nice)
robscastle
home | projects | blog
8547 posts in 3662 days
#9 posted 05-08-2019 10:50 PM
Dave, you being a musicial wiz, and me reading the replies prompted me to think you may enjoy this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDSN1F72QU4
-- Regards Rob
Dave Rutan
home | projects | blog
2022 posts in 3646 days
#10 posted 05-09-2019 12:54 PM
Ha ha! Good one!
-- Ni faru ion el ligno!
robscastle
home | projects | blog
8547 posts in 3662 days
#11 posted 11-14-2019 07:25 AM
Hi Dave,
I found something here that you may be interested in
https://www.lumberjocks.com/Gbluee/blog/130305#comment-4914578
-- Regards Rob
Dave Rutan
home | projects | blog
2022 posts in 3646 days
#12 posted 11-14-2019 12:02 PM
Thanks for thinking of me Rob. Yes, I actually bought one of these a few months back thinking I will need it should I actually build a fiddle from scratch.
-- Ni faru ion el ligno!
Have your say...